Vault loot help

So i got my first vault today and im asking for advice on what piece to get. (only been back for about a week and figuring things out still) Also i’m a holy priest

My top two items i got are ilvl 272 Deaths god signet 146 stam, 207 haste, 83 mastery Currently wearing(ilvl 255 ritual commander’s ring 119 stam 101 crit 161 vers and ilvl 236 flesh fused circle 69 crit 162 mastery (wow head says this is one of my best rings) )

Other item Offhand Natharian Tabernacle ilvl 265 179 int, 120 stam, 35 crit, 50 vers. Wearing currently(vessle of shining radiance 137 int, 84 stam, 47 crit, 28 mastery) wow head says this is one of my better offhands as well

I guess which to choose is my question, if going for the massive Ilvl bump between my two rings the best or should I do the offhand? Or will it really not matter too much?

Depends on what you’re doing. Looks like you’re playing Holy Priest.

For Hpriest, Haste is only really going to be used in dungeon/pvp.

I won’t comment on PvP really, since I haven’t been doing it on my priest. But for higher M+, you basically want Int > Haste + Crit or Haste + Verse. (Verse more important the higher your key level goes - think 20+ keys)

In Raid, you should be Prioritizing Int over all else still, but when the int gain is negligible, then Mastery+Crit should be the focus and Verse is also good there.

In conclusion:

Most likely take the offhand. You’ll probably replace it with a better weapon later, but the ring’s stats are really only beneficial for M+ or Spriest.

If you do plan to do Spriest a lot though, the ring’s not a bad choice for it.