Varian may be with the Light while Tirion(who died days after Varian did) simply had the Light intervene with his reanimation.
If the Jailer started taking Souls after Varian’s death and the Light knew this it would probably attempt to keep the location of Tirion’s Soul a secret as much as possible in order to maintain it’s followers’ faith in the Light!
They said its been going on for years so its probably been a lot longer than just Legion.
Then again Bwonsamdi gets souls in BFA. See what I mean none of this was thought through.
Unless mind control is the sole cause for her actions, she’s responsible for them, fully or in large part. However damaged her mind, she still performed the actions and so should get any punishment due for them.
Perhaps part of the blame goes to the necromancer, and so that person should get their judgement and punishment in due course. Undead grandma Sally gets her punishment, perhaps lessened slightly, but she still deserves punishment.
I agree with an earlier poster that eternal punishment is obscene, but a period is warranted.
I took it as Sylvanas had the capacity of doing what she did in undeath back in life before she died, too. She just didn’t have a reason to. And what sent her to the Maw was her acting on that capacity.
I wanted to revisit here after getting a little more in depth with Chronicles 4.
Let’s start here: Thus a new Arbiter was created one who used not only absolute knowledge of a soul, but also compassion to assign them to the proper place in the afterlife.
Just how many souls deserve a redo on their judgement? That’s rhetorical