I have:
[Mastercraft Kalu’ak Fishing Pole] = +13 Fishing + 4 Fishing enchant
[Nat Pagle’s Extreme Anglin’ Boots] = +5 Fishing
[Sharpened Tuskarr Spear] = +5 Fishing to any1 in 15 yds
[Nat’s Hat] = +5 Fisning + Lure +10 Fishing for 10min
[Worm Supreme] = Lure + 10 Fishing for 10min
I cant use [Nat’s Hat] or [Worm Supreme]
But was able to use
[Sharpened Fish Hook] = Lure +9 Fishing for 10min
[Bright Baubles] = Lure +7 Fishing for 10min
As I know there is no cap on Fishing, there for Items with [Lure +10 Fishing for 10min] are not working properly = broken.