Trans Women ARE Women

[Briselody-lightnings-blade (Briselody)]

@Kelliste-antonidas

Funny how the people who claim others are sexist or whatever are the exact thing that they hate.

[Kelliste-antonidas (Kelliste)]

If I want to be a what? What is a woman? How do I know what I want to be when I dont know what that thing is?

[Kaercha-area-52]

Ah, and now you’ve hit the crux of the argument.

If you want to be treated like a woman by society, and present yourself that way, then you are a woman.

[Azsharas-korgath]

a man is adult XY and a woman is adult XX…nothing can change this.
(that we know of, because maybe some mad scientist doing illegal work will figure out how to mix how fish/frogs change genders into humans)

the only time this doesn’t apply if when you have a mutation XXY/XXX/XYY/etc…which are so rare…but even then usually one set of traits is more dominate.

also are you telling me that all the men who say they are trans winning sports are not different then woman? cause seem to me they just doing it for the money as a lot of money in sports…and if your a nobody in the mens team but all the sudden world first as a woman lot of money to be had.

also a guy in a dress is drag, but still a man

a masculine dressing woman is tom boy, but still a woman

[Caféaulait-burning-blade]

happy black dog (crow) jumping on the streets

[Tovi-moon-guard (Tovi)]

@Jàrèd-dalaran

You need to chill a bit, I am calling the practice it, because I lived with it and have a very accurate view of it. The fact your parents do it has nothing to do with it, Don’t know your parents nor would I care if they were in front of me and saying it, I would say the same thing. You are choosing to put it as an insult to them, when its just to premise. You have seen enough of me or my demon hunters responses to know if I was insulting them, I have 0 qualms in saying them.

I have no idea what you said here because it doesn’t make sense. All I know is you said this:

Instilling a stupid archaic title that you force isn’t going to help that

You’re saying that making a child call their parents “mom” and “dad” is stupid and archaic.

I made my child call me mom and my husband dad. My parents did the same to me. You’re saying that me and my parents are being stupid and archaic then being miffed when I get offended.

So no I don’t need to chill. I see nothing wrong with my irritated reply.

[Vicktoria-area-52 (Vicktoria)]

what if a guy just likes wearing more feminie clothes, like some of the actors have done in the past
are we to assume they are women?
I dont want to mislabel someone from the outside looking in it can be unclear
becasue if somone presents female Im geing told Im supposed to assume they are a women and use the correct pronous, I say thing with the upmost honesty
its legitamtly confusing

[Jàrèd-dalaran]

A woman is what she says she is. Plain and simple. As Karcha said, if they present themselves as a woman, and say they are a woman, they are a woman.

[Kaercha-area-52]

@Vicktoria-area-52

what if a guy just likes wearing more feminie clothes, like some of the actors have done in the past
are we to assume they are women?

That’s a trans vestite. Not the same thing as transgender.

[Kelliste-antonidas (Kelliste)]

Treated like what? Whats a woman? If I dont know what a woman is, how can I know if I want to be treated like one and present as something that I dont know what that thing is?

[Allibankalt-moon-guard]

Your chromosomes determine your sex, XX and XY. Cant change those <3

Socially and Gender based you are how you present. That can be male, female, neither, both, trans, and anything else in between.

Glad I could help <3

[Briselody-lightnings-blade (Briselody)]

@Vicktoria-area-52

becasue if somone presents female Im geing told Im supposed to assume they are a women and use the correct pronous, I say thing with the upmost honesty

You can always just ask, and if there’s any confusion then they/them is always safe.

[Fenelon-wyrmrest-accord]

@Kelliste-antonidas

How do I know what I want to be when I dont know what that thing is?

You’re so close to understanding.

@Tahbitha-kilrogg

Sex = Gender

They are two words which mean the same thing, or at least they did before folks changed the definition of “gender” to support a lie.

Stop Using Phony Science to Justify Transphobia

[Jàrèd-dalaran]

@Tovi-moon-guard

You’re saying that me and my parents are being stupid and archaic then being miffed when I get offended.

Because that is my view of that premise. Someone can have a stupid and archaic view on something…but not be stupid themselves. You do realize that right?

Edit: Also seriously reread it. I said the title is stupid and archaic. You literally just quoted me on it.

[Kaercha-area-52]

Well, see it depends on what society you live in, because it’s a social construct.

[Kelliste-antonidas (Kelliste)]

Let them work through it. They cant actually answer the question of what is a woman even though it has a singular definition. An adult human female.

[Briselody-lightnings-blade (Briselody)]

And yet so very, very far lol

Ope, finally closed. Mazel tov!