As painful as it would be, that would be good. It was a bandaid fix to manage server population issues, and we should move away from it if we can, or go whole hog and add matchmaking for everything.
The community has these behaviors so ingrained that Blizzard will have to break things before it can be fixed. Otherwise, for the sake of new players, they ought to remove talents and other choices entirely. I don’t think they are going to do that.
I actually just randomly had an idea, maybe add rewards to things for deliberately playing them off meta, like complete a mythic+ _ with x class or x talents and the group gets a slightly better rewards, expand and refine that across the game?
All I know is people typically respond better to a reward for going out of their way rather than a punishment for not following the developers vision.
The content in shadowlands is being designed with covenants in mind. You all are applying covenants to what you experience in BFA. You will be able to complete content no matter what covenant you choose. If you decline people because they didn’t choose the covenant Icy Veins told you to pick, that’s a you problem not a system problem.
Especially since the game was fun for the better part of a decade until the new dev team showed up and started ruining it. Wouldn’t it make more sense for the new devs to move on, rather than the playerbase?
Blizzard Have proven time and time again that if they were in a 10 foot hole with a 10 foot ladder and a shovel they would chose the shovel every time. SMH.
And you can clear all the Mythic raids on any spec you choose, I know, I’ve cleared them as a Guardian Druid, but I can tell you for a fact that it would have been 10 times easier and 20 times more fun if I was a Brewmaster.
“You can do it if you walk through hot coals” is not reason to disregard game balance.
No one would take the time to go to a website and create a thread about a game they hate. This is the game they love, and they simply want it to be better.
We’ve seen the same exact mistakes the devs are making before They seem to be doubling down on them instead of learning from them. That is hella frustrating when you know it’s going to affect you’re gaming experience for the next few years. The toxicity comes from that frustration.