How? Provide evidence. What specifically do you use in combat?
And, More specifically, Why would these go AWAY if Tinker was to get added?
Grenades, rocket boost, glider, stealthman, etc. I didnât say they would go away stop using strawman. I said it would cannibalize new items. Gadgets are for engineering, period.
These are for leveling the profession
Good job, you have a Mobility skill. Movement utility. Not a damage dealer
When is this useful against a raid boss? Or in a dungeon? 
A movement utility
Helps you say out of combat. I Guess. But not a combat ability
Again. 90% of what you listed is Utility.
Engineering is the Profession about making utility items.
Tinker would be about dealing direct damage to the Enemy, and using mechanical know-how to fight their enemies. With Rotational combat abilities focused on technology, Missiles, ETC.
And the Engineering profession could still get craftable utility items, just like they have been getting.
Gadgets are for engineering. Period. They provide utilities and stuff. Itâs cool. But it has nothing to do with tinker at all.
If you wanna fight enemies with Missles, rockets, and a Mech suit. You play Tinker.
If you Wanna build gadgets that give you an edge and utilities. You pick up the Engineering profession.
You could even do BOTH. Since one is 100% combat focused and the other one has utilities both inside and outside of combat.
Apparently you have never pvpâd in your entire existence. The game is not all about dungeons.
I hate to break your little heart. But no. I donât care about PvP
But. I PROMISE YOU with 100% surety that Engineer will STILL get craftable bombs every expansion.
So Tinkers could exist, and have bomb and missile based attacks, AND you could still be an Engineer and craft bombs
Even if you Hate tinker and never play one. I guarantee you that Engineering will still have Rocket boots, Gliders, Bombs, and Stealth-boys.
Because you make UTILITY Items. But you ARENâT a Class.
Good, nobody cares about your tinker. You want people to care while ignoring other parts of the game people care about.
We donât need your overlap joke of a âclassâ which is more of a transmog than anything. We need something novel that adds depth to the game.
Why add anything in then? Nothing seems to be new mechanically. Add in a dot class. Oh, affliction exists. Add in double jump. Oh wait, jump exists, you just do it twice now. Glide? Slow fall, except you can control what direction you go it. Greater pyroblast? Orange chaos bolt with a longer cast timer.
Quite a few care about it here.
Then you suggest something. A new class is generally pretty good at that, especially since tinker isnât alike to any class we have, and has minimal similarities to engineering.
Double jump was completely new. You can âoh coolâ it all you want but it adds depth to the game.
Iâm sure thatâs why there are tinker threads. 
Because nobody cares, thatâs why we make so many threads.
Tinkers donât overlap. Weâve established that Tinker abilities currently donât exist in World of Warcraft. so Who do they overlap with? Please enlighten me.
What class EXACTLY would you transmog to turn into a tinker?
New DPS Specs, New Tank specs, and possibly new healer specs do add depth to the game. Because itâs more stuff to Min-max and figure out.
Double jump existed in game, you could just do 50% of it. It added in DHs looking cool and breaking stuff like dungeons.
Relatively you represent about .01% of the gameâs population. It is not significant.
They do overlap, you even just said so about bombs.
Tinker is a remix/transmog of existing abilities. GG no re.
No, it didnât. You could never jump twice and reach places the way they can.
Whoa!!! Thereâs a class that uses bombs?! Where?!!!
That would be aweomse~!
Which abilities?
What ability is like a Mech suit?
Yeah, every one in the game that uses engineering.
A mech suit is a graphic.
tencharacters
Not the same thing lol
What Advantage does a Demon Hunter get by double jumping to new places? Thereâs no special vendors up there, and enemies can reach you anyways.
Show me the DPS charts where Engineering bombs are better than Class abilities.
Hmm⌠You know What, Warlock Metamorphosis was just a graphic. All those warlock players shouldnât be upset that they lost the fantasy they loved. After all, it was just a graphic. People donât care about those.
100% of your âargumentâ boils down to âI Donât like them, so they shouldnât existâ
Tinkers would literally take NOTHING from the Engineering profession at all. You could still make utilities and useless little bombs.
Here comes Averyx should I be excited
1 Like
Players cannot reach you, and it allows you to kite with massive advantage, even in your precious dungeons.
bombs donât have to do better dps to be useful.
^^Big strawman I never said anything of the sort, keep up the fallacies.
100% of your argument boils down to remixing existing mechanics. Tinkers would take things that would normally be reserved for engineers.
Thereâs also the alchemist from WC3 that could be directly baked into a tinker spec.
Most importantly, itâs the only fantasy archtype weâre missing. We have strong guys, dark classes, agility classes, magic, mystical and martial artists yet we donât have smart guys who build their own weaponry.
Tinker could be awesome.