This tank spec is mud

Conceding to the way things are as implemented by blizzard, letting go of the expectation of balance despite understanding that rarely have we seen Brewmaster be able to push title.

You’re seeming to argue against the OP saying he needs to play something easier which is pointlessly condescending for anyone being serious about the M+ situation for Brewmaster. Every serious Brewmaster player knows what he’s talking about, and we certainly don’t need less Brewmaster players if we ever want to see a fix.

The damage split between the 6th tank and the 2nd tank is 100k DPS. For point of comparison the damage split between the 2nd tank and the first tank is also 100k DPS. We need not feel good about brew’s damage either, the tank beating us in this department brings actual group utility.

1 Like

I am sick of brew so I rolled on my pally with trash 600ilvl, did 2 keys 10, both were timed +2. Amd I did as much as my 625 prot war. Why brew when pally exists ?

I don’t know what ‘push title’ means

an arguement tends to show itself in a ‘heated’ or ‘intense’ way … by no means was my vocabulary such … it was a simple (albeit failed) Reasoned Persuasion … kinda … to explain that on average DK’s were below Brews in DPS… upon which he did say that :

So that gave way to my talking point … of course what I said about issues of their gameplay probably provoked an air of negativity which wasn’t my point but rather an unfounded assumption … and we all know what they say about assumptions …

True

The top .1% of players in Mythic+ get a title.

To be top .1% in the past few seasons looks like this

Season Raiting Requirement Highest Brewmaster Brews with title
Dragonflight S4 3653.96 3639.1 0
Dragonflight S3 3688.18 3753.6 5
Dragonflight S2 3225.12 3748.4 *148
Dragonflight S1 3378.85 3506.8 *10
Season Raiting Requirement Highest Demon Hunter DH with title
Dragonflight S4 3653.96 3930.1 *372
Dragonflight S3 3688.18 4033.1 *764
Dragonflight S2 3225.12 3871.1 *686
Dragonflight S1 3378.85 3506.1 *6
  • *I did not check the regions for players

https://raider.io/mythic-plus-character-rankings/season-df-4-cutoffs/world/monk/tank
https://raider.io/mythic-plus/cutoffs/season-tww-1/us

because i cannot be a worgen paladin
:dracthyr_cry_animated:

2 Likes

wow - that actually depresses me -

  • s4 we were virtually unkillable and no one got title ??

but tbh thats when double sigil was the play - why would you play anything else ?

I am truly beginning to think the rest of the season will be Paladins time to shine with all the non-stop casters and now Paladin the only one who can handle such things at a decent rate

Warriors an paladins this expansion :slight_smile:

Lots of DH’s in the MDI so dont forget about them

Yes Paladins who had the following representation in the top 2000 keys:

  • DF Season 1 - 82% Representation
  • DF Season 2 - 65% Representation
  • DF Season 3 - 42% Representation

But they did miss being good for one season so, lets fix that.

I just remember in alpha/beta and first few weeks of this season - Prot was worse off than Brew - smh

Yeah every time this season so far a tank has approached being as bad as Brewmaster, it gets buffed. Weird…

Though the latest Blood DK changes seem mostly damage focused and didn’t really have them pull away from us.

DH needs everythimg to go just right or it will fall over. So while DH is better than Monk I wouldnt really want to be in thier place.

Prot Paladin was never worse than brew. Paladins are like mages, if their spec is average or below they collectively go nuts and claim to be unplayable. They were doing higher keys than Brew before the buffs.

Blizzard buffed them according to the outrage which is why they skyrocketed to meta.

It is like groundhog day with paladins.

VDH is designed to be MDI tank. It scales extremely well with pull size. Its uncapped AoE cc are extremely valuable in mass pulls. Its 2 min cd meta synergizes so well with MDI pull pace.
Bjt it doesn’t make it a good tank for lesser pulls. In the final last week MDI, a full bis 639 fell over to a single trash pull in SoB11 after he lost his cds in the previous wipe.

1 Like