Because lets be real, she will be redeemed somehow… I want Lor’themar to figure out that Blightcaller is the real enemy and that he has been controlling Sylvanas through the Hungerer for the last 2 expansions…
Tyrande, Alleria, and Vereesa team up on Sylvanas, while Lor’themar and Malfurion kill the Blightcaller releasing Sylvanas from his “tentacles”…
Lol thats my nerd lore story for this Sunday… Your welcome.
Do those even still work once you’re undead?
Unless Blightcaller is a world class actor he’s likely much more probable to be the brainwashed one, he acts like a literal zombie. Plus undead are immune to most forms of mind control… especially of an Old god influence.
The only way I want Sylvanas redeemed is in fire.
Fire purifies. Burn it all.
Honestly, Sylvanas needs to die, horribly and painfully, and be locked away, still concious in spirit, but get to sit and slowly fade away as she gets weaker and weaker, and the world as a whole recognizes her as the idiot she’s been since WC3, and eventually the world simply forgets about her, just another stupid psychotic elf whom attempted to destroy the world in pursuit of personal power and self interests.
… I kinda want more on this.
Maybe a detailed manga?
Them elves be cray cray
She won’t be redeemed, but we won’t kill her either. What will probably happen is that her plan will be to steal the Jailer’s power and then try to usurp the Arbiter’s role, so she can rule all of the afterlife for all time.
We’ll stop her by sealing her away in the Jailer’s place, so that she becomes the new ruler of the Maw, trapped there forever. No longer needing to worry about hell, or even dying again, but also only getting drip fed souls of the worst of the worst, and a prisoner once again.
So she’ll ‘save us’ from the Jailer, try to take over, and then be beaten.
I bet Sargeras is craving a cellmate right now. Illidan probably isn’t much in the way of good conversation.
You can only listen to a person talk about how great Tyrande is for so long before you just want to start purging all life from the universe… again.
That’s been my guess.
She’s keen on “fixing” the afterlife, I have a feeling she will be trapped there to keep it fixed.
Hey, who knows? It could save the tattered story thread that ran through BFA.
Or really really want Tyrande 
… that’d be a hilarious development.
If they try to redeem her and whitewash the genocide, I will probably stop playing the game for good. I’ve boycotted for less.
Seconded wholeheartedly.
My Theory is that she’ll get made mortal again, but for all her “betrayal” the Horde wants her dead, but Anduin he will take her into the Alliance. Which will pit Horde vs Alliance once more and more intense then ever!
No. She will burn.
She’d be dead within an hour. If not by Night Elves, then by Shaw.
I’ve read enough bad fanfiction to know where this is going.
I say we send her back to the maw, so she can get more acqauinted with…“tentacles” and many other types of writhing limbs, I’m sure she’ll find her created Night elf amalgam abominations quite good company… 
…There is a very strange fixation on tentacles in this thread that is starting to make me uncomfortable.