I think itâs important to answer these questions:
Is the high-elf/blood-elf (fair skinned, majestic elf) a CORE horde race? Is it STEALING a horde theme, giving the Alliance a similar elf race, be it High-Elf or Half-Elf?
All elves are essentially ideal humans, untrained eyes will say blood elves are just thinner/prettier humans. This isnât a problem in conventional fantasy games because in those games, the elves are usually sided with humans and dwarves (short humans), so their subtle differences are considered enough.
But in World of WarCraft this isnât the case, so this becomes a big problem because the two sides are too similarââthe fair skinned, majestic elves are never meant to fight the humans, otherwise they wouldâve been made way too different. Currently it feels more like the Huns (allegedly ugly in historical record) fighting the Europeans (with their narrow face), just human VS. human.
So this isnât something to be proud of, and to treat it as a hallmark/specialty of WOW is absurd. Itâs not good, itâs bad. The proofs of this are: The blood elves never represent the horde (donât even show in CG/posters), their leaders donât do anything meaningful⊠And the existence of High Elf in the Alliance.
If the Blood Elf image screams HORDE, then why does the Alliance have High Elves? Clearly even the developers, the lore makers didnât feel right, to make the fair skinned, majestic elf Horde exclusive. Thereâs nothing to be exclusive of, it would be like sayingâHere this faction has humans, and that totally different faction has prettier/thinner humans. How unique is that!
Now I understand people move, thereâs no reason two factions canât have the same race. I can perfectly accept a human variation (prettier, thinner etc.) also represented in the monster faction. Itâs all about suspense of disbelief. But making a human variation extinct in the human faction, and at the same time claiming itâs a CORE race of the monster factionâThatâs a bit much donât you think?
Making the High Elf extinct would imply that the Alliance restrict peopleâs movement (because people move), as far as I know the Alliance does no such thing. So unless this is something I donât know about, we have no choice but to accept, that the High Elf exist in the Alliance.
They exist, so thereâll always be a possibility that High Elf or Half Elf becomes playable. Some may choose going back to Silvermoon city (so the Horde can have High Elf). Some may even act as spies for the Horde. Whacho gonna do? But all these doesnât change the fact that, the fair skinned, majestic elf donât live in one place.
When you live in different countries, you contribute to the local communities, you donât actively sabotage your new home. You pray thereâd better not be war, but when it happens it happens, and there are rules and duties in place, regardless of who the enemy are.