Just posting some thoughts I’ve been having lately. Not sure what kind of useful discussion could come of this, it always seems like these days people rush to enforce the status quo, to defend the indefensible, to brandish people as “noobs” and to insult and discredit anyone with an idea counter to Blizzard’s current zeitgeist.
But its clear that Discipline Priest might as well not exist anymore. With keys becoming more popular activity for semi-casual players without the time for raiding, its easy to see from raider IO’s leaderboards that only 3 to 4% of all healers are playing Disc in 10 to 15 keys, and by the time you get to lvl 20 keys for the portal achievements, the representation drops to near non-existent levels.
This used to be one of the most popular healing specs, and when most of the community was begging for Disc to be nerfed in Pandaria, I think any sane Priest was on board with this idea as well. And yet Blizzard never acted on this, never nerfed when nerfs were necessary, and that irresponsible lack of action created a huge anti-Disc sentiment, which I believe led to the Devs over-correcting in Legion, with a re-work nobody wanted.
And its clear nobody wanted it, by how few people are playing Disc now.
This isn’t a question of the spec being broken or unplayable, as there is certainly no question someone is rushing to post something of that sort even before they get this far into my post. You can have a spec that is entirely functional, but that is also essentially useless due to its redundant nature or anti-fun mechanics that drive players away. And that is what Disc is now.
The spec that is supposed to be “do damage while healing” is checking all the boxes to fulfill that definition, while also being one of the healers that will do less damage than several other “vanilla” healing specs, unless they are Kyrian, in which case most people play Holy anyway since most of the damage comes entirely from the Kyrian Covenant ability, and not anything specific to Discipline spec itself. Again, this is represented in the m+ stats on raider IO.
Now Holy Priest, Resto Shaman (of course - the devs favored spec), Resto Druid, are all doing better damage. For Free!!! essentially, as there is no tax applied to them for the damage they do, as there is for Disc. Holy’s Smite hits almost 3 times as hard as Disc’s does. Why? Cause of Historical factors leading to negative perception from the community, toward the “doing damage while healing” spec. And so now almost every other healing spec can do more damage than Disc, for FREE!!!
If you can still manage to find a good Paladin or Mistweaver, whose popularity is also on the decline, they can do more damage (Paladin) or keep pace (Mistweaver) with the Disc spec. Again, for free, and with comparable or better utility.
PW: shield has been nerfed into virtually complete irrelevance, if it weren’t for Rapture or a lack of good ways to spread Atonement, why use that spell? Its not efficient on mana, and having a Mastery that increases absorbs and healing, when both are extremely lackluster, is salt on the wound. +20% bonus to garbage doesn’t even get you to average. Remember Divine Aegis as the Mastery? I bet hardly anyone does. Cataclysm was the best Disc ever has been, and probably ever will be again.
They just don’t make them like they used to. And its sad, and the game is worse off for it. Shadowlands, with its extended talent trees, is shaping up to be more like how the game used to be. Disc deserves another look. The way it is now, its always going to be a “fine on paper” spec that Extremely Smart People will say it works, doesn’t need any adjustment, and its Really Good®™ (trust us) spec, if you just “get good” at the game.
Fact is though, I’m good enough to know trash when I see it. And I won’t be touching that spec again. There’s a reason why everyone acknowledges just how integral trash men are to the proper functioning of society, and yet virtually no one is rushing out to become one. The spec gets the job done. If you hate yourself.
At this point I’m just like, sure guys. Lets continue to watch your MAU’s (cause calling them subs is just not sophisticated enough, just like not enjoying Disc isn’t sophisticated) drop cause you lost the plot. In before someone calls me a troll for having logical thoughts.