I feel like this would be better as a BLP system that opens in the back half of the season. I think fully deterministic gearing in pve is kinda bleh. But it’s a solid framework.
I think we need a good mix from both to get the best gear though. The tokens for tier helps in raids, also the rings and trinkets from raid are generally bis.
You can just buy your BIS weapon and trinket from the raid with the 2 dinars we’ll be getting. My bis weapon is Best-In-Slots, which I and 99% of players have no shot of getting the Myth track version of anyways if dinars didn’t exist because it’s a Very Rare drop from the 6th raid boss
Yes, that is why we should remove gear dropping from raid n make raiding purely for ego purpose and maybe cosmetics. Raiding is such an obsolete system it should have been removed long ago.
Make all gear from from M+ and delves.
Trinkets I agree even though there’s always a Sacrabrood type from M+ it seems that everyone wants.
For Weapons it’s not that egregious since with the ease of getting Gilded Crests everyone can get 675 Weapons crafted which are usually sim pretty close to a Mythic Raid Weapon.
Then you have outliers like this spec (WW) who’s BIS weapon comes from M+ and thus the Vault.
This isn’t true. I’ve gotten the majority of my gear from raid drops. I was getting literally 0 gear from the 10s of M+ I was running every week. Unless you are lucky and you need stats no one else needs, everyone else is farming the same haste/mast stuff as you.
A M+ run takes 20-40 minutes on top of finding a group. So you’re looking at a good hour to get 2-3 pieces among 5 ppl, with the hope that 1 piece will be your bis, and that it drops for you, or no one needs it early season (highly unlikely).
Meanwhile most raid bosses drop at least one piece + token which can save you a catalyst charge. If you’re in a guild you can reduce competition by playing a niche armor type/stat or by just being good.
Running 10 10+s will take you hours and hours of work, full clearing heroic will take you maybe 2 hours tops right now.
Meanwhile I’m sitting here at 663 lvl, 3/8 Mythic bosses defeated and working on the 4th, and my gear consists of:
3 items from raid (Heroic ring + Heroic tier piece + Heroic wrists) - and the wrists get replaced with crafted next week
2 items from delves (neck + trinket)
6 items from M+ (Mythic tier chest, Mythic tier legs, Mythic tier shoulders, Mythic cloak, Mythic boots, Heroic trinket)
3 crafted (weapon, belt, gloves) for which the crests largely came from m+
M+ is vastly superior in terms of gearing than raid. It’s just undeniable.