While Phase 3 Incursions did serious harm to SoD. Having Season of Mastery raids in SoD is probably the final nail in the coffin. After my guild blew up because of our 2 20 man rosters only 8 people of 40 wanted to still raid after we found out they were using SoM raids (we all played SoM and hated the raids) I decided to pug.
It’s ridiculous how many pugs fall apart on Heat 1 because the average classic player can’t handle 2 Living Bombs on Baron Geddon or cant properly move away from Shazzrah’s images, or struggle with Harbinger.
The devs completely ignored what makes Classic Classic this time around for the raids. Players wanted the same Classic 2019 raids but with increases to Boss Health and Damage to compensate for our increased power, NOT mechanical changes. No one wants Ragnaros to force submerge and unable to out dps the mechanic to possibly wipe because the average classic player cant do the submerge mechanic.
Molten Core (and BWL, AQ40, Naxx40) should be tuned for 20 players and allow up to 40 players like Onyxia and World Bosses. There shouldn’t be toggleable difficulties like Heat 1, Heat 2, Heat 3, there should be 1 difficulty.
The majority of players who play Classic Era, and SoD, want easy raids where they can relax and hang out with friends while having Beer (Soda) and Pretzels and turn off their brain and get some loot. That’s why the Classic 2019 raids were successful, they don’t want Retail raids.
The sad thing is, aside from the SoM mechanics for MC and Onyxia, Phase 4 is actually a good phase. The new dungeon DFC is actually fun. The real vendor is great and keeps players playing dungeons once they hit full pre-raid BiS so they can buy a couple of crafting reagents for BiS gear or to sell for some gold for consumes.
If Phase 4 had the Classic 2019 Raids but with increased HP/DMG and MC to have up to 40 players there is no doubt in my mind that Phase 4 would be popping off. Instead we have MC Heat 1 where more than half the pugs I’m in can’t do simple mechanics because the average classic player can’t deal with 2 living bombs at the same time on Baron Geddon and fall apart.