Not exactly. I don’t remember all the math and am not good at that kind of math anyway, but the value of health increases as you add armor. The concept of “Effective Health”.
The more armor you have, the better health is as a stat because all physical damage is reduced by your armor before being calculated.
It is 5% bonus to base stamina, not stamina in general. So, as a Tauren at level 60, you will have around 140 more health than other races and it will not improve because your base stamina will never improve. It’s not worth rolling a Tauren for the extra 140 health. If you roll a Tauren, do it because you like the looks.
Edit: I was corrected, it does seem to be 5% of total health, not base. Even still it is negligible. It shouldn’t be your reason for choosing the race if you prefer Orc/Troll/Undead. I personally prefer Tauren, but the extra health is not even a factor for me.
I remember in the waning days of Vanilla there being a forum post of a Night Elf warrior having just over 10k hp in Naxx, and it being a big deal.
I mained a Tauren warrior tank, and it’s really not that big of a deal. Asking, “Did the HP racial save that wipe?” is so meta, it’s not really worth worrying about. Just keep Shield Block on maximum up-time and you’ll be fine, +5% hp or no
If that is true, I guess I remember it incorrectly. Even still, in absolute best gear with all buffs, you might only be looking at 300 - 400 health extra. It’s not worth it unless you actually want to play Tauren because you like how they look and their animations. I personally like Tauren because in plate gear they look amazing, the extra health is a bonus.
Yeah, realistically with Classic health pools you aren’t going to be getting a huge amount from it.
Like most racials it’s just more a preference thing.
In all honesty I think the increased attack range is the Tauren’s best racial and that isn’t even an actual racial lol.
This is a weird comparison. Add a third one that increases your threat generated and most people are going to gravitate towards the threat generation. Health regen is worthless, making yourself a bit more of a damage sponge is nearly as worthless. Defense is far more valuable than stamina and threat is also very important.
Armguards of the Troll
Shoulder
+9 Str
+10 Sta
+1% Attack Speed
Health regeneration rate increased by 10%. 10% of total Health regeneration may continue during combat.
Armguards of the Tauren
Shoulder
+9 Str
+45 Sta
Use: Stuns up to 5 enemies within 8 yds for 2 sec. (2 min Cooldown)
“You are HUGE!”
I couldn’t care less. The extremely rare situation that 150 health will save someone isn’t useful. Berserking lets the DPS go harder, and even then it doesn’t matter.
EDIT: On use is far better than a flat increase, it lets you include it in a burst phase which is where the DPS are going to be generating a lot of threat.