Talent Tree Needs Flexibility

The original WoW (Modern / retail) taught us that talent trees need characters need more flexibility. In reality, characters aren’t only one role (tank / DPS / heals). Raiders all have raid specs, which may not be their favorite. For levelling, it’s close to universal to level in a DPS spec. Some tank specs can level well. Heal specs tend to not die, but also take a very long time to kill anything with the low damage output. As the saying goes, you can’t heal someone to death.

Forever adds another dimension. This version of WoW is supposed to be about other styles than racing to level cap and min-maxing using the standard build you find on a website. According to pre-launch descriptions, it was supposed to be about taking your time, and exploring. But the cost of changing talents means that at lower levels, you simply can’t change often. There’s no opportunity to experiment with the different styles of your character. The very high cost of talent changes (relative to when you’re levelling) prevents players from changing often. Veteran retail players may be able to make a good guess based on the names of the icons, but if anyone else spends a talent point, they’re stuck with it. That exploration and learning process has been cut off by the price and inconvenience wall. So, people will just follow a cookie-cutter build on their favorite website, or for true newbies, will just do a poor job and be stuck with it, frustrated with their character.

Also, it’s burdensome to head back to a capital to change. So, imagine the classic WoW dungeon group, where the heals has been levelling in DPS spec and wants to join. The whole group must wait while they return to capital, run to the trainer, pay to change spec, redo a spec (hopefully having it screenshotted or memorized), and then make their way to the dungeon.

In short, we already learned a lesson in Modern, and that lesson needs to be adopted in Forever. Characters need to be able to store multiple specs already built and ready to go, with swaps in the field. Since different specs go with different gear, characters need gear sets that can swap with the talent specs. In other words, just do it like retail.

I could argue for more talent build slots. Most classes have three main specs. Druids have four. Sometimes even a single role can benefit from multiple specs (AoE / single target DPS, for instance.) Modern only has two slots (last time I played). But if Forever really wants to encourage exploring the possibilities with one character, it really needs to improve on Modern and allow for more spec builds – somewhere between three and, oh, six. These are presumably stored locally and so not a burden on Blizzard resources.

There’s argument that players want something, therefore it should be hard to get so they value it. There’s at least a little merit to that philosophy, but it shouldn’t lead to making the game more tedious and time consuming. That’s not increasing engagement; it’s adversarial GMing.

If Forever is going to live up to its billing as an experience where we can explore and grow horizontally, we need dimensions to explore, like additional specs that are easy to change, both in time and resources. If it’s just another race to the level cap, like Modern – well, we should just play Modern, because it has vastly more content and many UI improvements over Forever.

Make Forever live up to its promise as a different experience.