Surprisingly, Sylvanas has completed her task in the Maw and thanks to the wibbly wobbly flow of time in the Maw she’s completed it in a year.
But the poor dear has no place to go to. Seems like grudges run deep and no amount of remorse will heal those wounds she’s caused.
So she begs you for a hand to help her out. Will you let by gones be by gones. Or shoo her away. Also she’ll be dragging along Nathanos and an owl that may or may not be house broken.
Let her stay in the new tree for max irony.
She probably would be safer there as a prisoner. Get rotten fruit and curses tossed her way but doubt Tyrande would want her killed out right so the NE’s can release their anger on her.
No solicitors.
Supposedly we lost five Azeroth years while in the Shadowlands, time should go way slower for her. 
I don’t know much about this Sylvanas lady and I have no clue what this “Maw” you speak of is but I have no home to offer her shelter in I’m constantly on the move.
I honestly liked Sylvanas. Call me crazy. I didn’t like her as warchief, I Just liked her as a supporting role crazy woman that was spooky and dead and liked dead things. Having her tag along for the quests in the 3 Icecrown dungeons was nice. Her plans to rez the dead in Cata to keep her race going was spooky and cool too. Garrosh getting all butthurt about it helped develop his character and his connection, or rather lack thereof to her and her motives.
The burning of the tree was the most full blown derp decision they ever made (in regards to Sylvanas’ character arc). That and the poisoning of Lordaeron. I think some good came from it, like her fight with Saurfang. Just the look on her face when he said she failed…that little subtle drop in her smile. God, just peak chills. But overall, they handled her character really poorly and sentencing her to The Maw felt like a total copout.
Bring her back but give her something actually interesting to do. Maybe it’s too late for that, but I actually love her past lore. She was done dirty.
As long as I can put Nathanos on a leash and shut him up , sure.
I’ll even make her coffee.
Nathanos will not be leaving the Shadowlands…perhaps not even the Maw. If he did manage to get out of the Maw, it would likely be to go to Revendreth…to be fitted with a very large and heavy sinstone.
Good. No one ever liked Nathanos, lol.
Don’t you call me hero! I sense that tone! I’ll get 39 of my friends and smote your little Undead head!
I dont think its too late.
They just need to make sure they dont dwell on the whole jailer story she got wrapped up in.
Bring her back, put her back with the forsaken, and pretend that whole mess never happened.
A sort of soft retcon.
I dunno man. That’s a big elephant in the room.
I just picture her going back to her spot in UC and all the Forsaken standing around like, “Ohhhhhkay, so what was that all about?” 
Nothing new if that happend,we’ve done that a few times now lol
The best expression was the the tink tink guard in BFA when she went off on her "is nothing " speech
no but i will help my love alleria out.
Speaking of the Saurfang fight I mentioned earlier, yes, I love that part. That one little slight glance was a huge gesture that basically exiled Sylvanas as any kind of respected leader. I mean yeah, she flew away and then basically denounced her position, but that one little Undead could see right through the anger and knew she messed up. It was never about the Horde, it was always about her.
I love those little touches, in cinematics like that. Little simple things that mean a lot, from a story perspective.
I have some property in Silithis with a giant sword, not sword, to sell her.
We could hollow it out and turn it into a tower of Orthanc
That was such a good cinematic - when she shouts “The horde is nothing” Saurfang had instantly won that battle, despite losing the fight.
Also the absolute BALLS on Saurfang to challenge Sylvanas one on one.
I also love that he didnt go out shouting For The Horde, it was For Azeroth.
this is like being asked would you let a mob boss hide out in your house, ID rather them owe me one them them gunning for me.
Regardless IF you have seen some past comments I actually wouldnt mind sylvanus chilling with me at all. I’d rather have them as allies then enemies. besides she is supposed to be going through some sort of redemption. Regardless of faction and morale my house would be seen as switzerland. No war just peace in it. 
Oh and his smile said it all too. He knew he beat her, despite losing his life. He lost the battle, won the war.
Also, if you notice, at the start of the fight, he said “let it be finished” which is exactly what his son said, at the Wrathgate. Nice little touch. 
I’ll help her lose her footing off of a cliff. I’m not trusting her again.