Sylvanas fans: so why do you hate Sylvanas so much?
Haters: well she committed a genocide!! she is evil how dare you like an evil character? you sick twisted freak!! at least i know who you would have voted for in Germany back in the 1920s if you were alive back then you evil person!!!
Sylvanas fans: why do you like Garrosh then? He blew up Theramore Isle he is evil he was racist and believed that Orcs were the only true horde and other races were unworthy.!
Haters: because he’s a legend he did nothing wrong.
Love whatever character you want just don’t be a hypocrite about it please stop using the “i am morally superior” card on us when arguing.
I love the joker in batman does it mean i want to blow up hospitals? No
For the dark lady!!!
46 Likes
This is a big generalization on the types of varied players that grow attached to these characters.
But also, for the Dark Lady!! 
11 Likes
Arthas did nothing wrong.
I’m just throwin’ that out there, wherever I can.
24 Likes
To be fair, there are plenty of people that think both should get an all-expenses paid trip to suffer in the Maw for eternity.
30 Likes
To be fair, Garrosh didn’t approve of what Sylvanas was doing either, I blame the writers for villain batting him in MoP, sure he did some terrible things but I don’t think MoP Garrosh is in character… the man throws a lieutenant off the battlements for bombing a bystanding settlement of innocent Druids, but then nukes a city with a Mana bomb? Yep that totally makes sense…
56 Likes
This sounds like a case of you getting mad at one person and pretending everyone is the same as them.
26 Likes
I also love Arthas!!! hahahaha <3
2 Likes
Oh don’t misunderstand . . . I despise both of them, but I give this much credit to Garrosh, at least he didn’t pretend he was doing what he did for some “greater good”, he owned his villainy and while I tend to hate villains (I’m a goodie two-shoes) at least he was honest.
Sylvanas however comes across as a petulant child, crying about how unfair life has been to her as if she’s the only one to have suffered this fate.
56 Likes
They offer you free drinks with little umbrellas if you serve the jailer.
Well at least Sylvanas told the jailer not to kill Bolvar, Jaina and Thrall after they got what they wanted.
She also gave Anduin a choice that she never had. she was struggling. i do know what she did was wrong but it is justified.
2 Likes
The stonetalon scene is actually the out of character one. The designer of that quest misread what the story team had planned for Garrosh.
6 Likes
Probably yeah.
all i see now sylvanas haters posting how great garrosh died etc. their double standards !!
1 Like
Same reason I respect Garrosh more… he wasn’t a flip-flop.
Sylvanas preaches about freedom of choice and all this I never serve crap. Okay? Explain how blight bombing Horde soldiers at the battle for Lordaeron was giving them a choice? Explain how blight bombing Gilneans was giving them a choice? Explain how condemning innocent civilians who don’t have anything to do with the war is giving them a choice? Explain how you didn’t realize the JAILER is a total embodiment of servitude and you spending the last couple years conducting his every whim to achieve his plans isn’t contributing to servitude? I mean. Garrosh was a bad guy, but he knows that and stands by it for the most part. Sylvanas on the other hand doesn’t know what she is. Talks all this about choice, while being the right hand of a soul enslaving tyrant.
38 Likes
No, nothing she did, has done, or may do is “justified”.
She gave Anduin a false choice, basically “your gonna serve, but you choose whether it’s willing or not.” and if you think she gave a kobold’s rear about Jaina, Thrall, and Bolvar then your deluding yourself almost as bad as she has deluded herself. Probably wanted to keep them around if she did at all so they could thank her for “setting us all free” what ever the funkwaggle that was supposed to mean.
21 Likes
People dont care about what sylvanas has done.
Theyre just using it as an excuse to hate on her more.
People are just fed up of seeing her in the spotlight. It got tiring with jaina, it got tiring with khadgar, it got super tiring with thrall to the point where people are still sick of him.
All sylvanas needs to do is sit out an expansion or 2 and people will be over it next time she shows up.
Apart from night elf players. Theyre legit crazy and will never get over. Ever. Even when the severs have gone down.
5 Likes
Why do people seem to think those of us who hate Sylvie love Garrosh?
I hated her since Cata because she’s a duplicitous witch who was willing to use blight upon her enemies.
I hate her more now because she’s now a poorly written duplicitous witch.
Garrosh I hated him but I could respect that he at least was consistent and believed he was doing the honorable thing to bring the Horde to glory.
32 Likes
Kinda why I’ve detested her too,after Wrath her character just got worse after each expansion but for some reason has a fanbase hellbent on simping for her at every turn no matter what she does. She could kick a puppy and they’d come up with some sass backwards mental gymnastics to try and justify it.
15 Likes
She is the manifestation of Blizzards do everything their way or hit the highway, literally everything else in Warcraft has gone down the toilet just to prop her for an unsatisfying arch that wasn’t earned.
His arch was done better. That why they killed him so he wouldn’t outshine their new pet.
11 Likes