Limited is the best term I have to describe it.
As far as suffering goes, guilds are suffering. The number of guilds that are on the way to collapse is staggering to watch. More than a few guilds have been in a state of creative drought, had some dodgy events happen, or just been impacted by the recent state of WoW and its creators, to the point that many are circling the drain. More than a few are holding up “on hiatus” as a futile reassurance that it’s not over, while others have straight up collapsed. Some have even capitulated into the larger, older guilds, leading to big monopolies that just own whatever their niche is. Not good, in my opinion.
MG-H especially is running mostly on legacy. There isn’t really a lot of new blood running things; it’s old names and old guilds who still coordinate all the projects like they did back in 2019 or earlier. Conversely, I feel like legacy isn’t enough for MG-A anymore. A lot of the older guilds are hitting stagnation and just being “known” is no longer enough to keep them afloat.
Walk up is about the same as it was a year ago. Alliance has more of it, Horde has less. Alliance is more consistent, Horde exists on spontaneity. Alliance has more strangers, Horde is more tight-knit. Locations are about the same - got a few districts in Stormwind for walk up, Valley of Honor for Orgrimmar.
I think the meat of the RP right now is in server events that people host. They’re almost consistently active with solid turn out every time. Went to a Pandaren festival the other day that had a lot of people show up and a lot of stellar work put into it. Planning to go to the Month’s End Brawl tonight if I can help it, which almost always has a big selection of people on both factions.
In fact, most of the time, when people want to show how active their community or guild is? They post screenshots from scheduled and coordinated events.
So as far as my anecdotal “honest insight” goes, guilds are in a bit of a poor state, walk up is relatively unchanged and you can most likely get some cool stuff going there, and events are currently a good way to find active people to network with and make friends.