So how many times are you going to force Jaina through the Horde player's throat...?

No, the book ends with the peace plan not actually happening. The lore was silent as to if ever Thrall/Jaina completed their agreement.

Even assuming Jaina/Thrall decided to have a ceasefire agreement between Theramore/Ogrimmar that does not mean Jaina became neutral in the same vein such an agreement would not make Thrall neutral.