400 iLVL before was heroic raid geared, 415, which I also mentioned and you didn’t, was M10/mythic raid geared. Right now I am just starting to gear my second alt this patch, sitting 414 iLVL (priest) with around 2 days work having done 5 M+ and zero raids, my other alt is 417 (DK) and has done no work aside from the intro quests this patch.
I have struggled so far on my priest to find a group above a +4 aside from the one run I done with my guild that I was lucky enough to get into. Players won’t take me because there are X number of other healers they know they can find if they wait long enough.
At this iLVL players start thinking I don’t have the gear, I don’t have the experience, I don’t have the essences. So far no one at a +7 or higher pug will take me, therefore I can only hope I find someone in my guild who has a lowish key that we can time, keep doing even lower keys until I am geared, or run with my guild on our Friday heroic runs.
It’s not about being efficient, nor is it about getting all the essences, but being able to successfully time a +10 this season with the extra difficulty, being able to pull your weight in a raid, it is best to get at least rank 2 of some essences at HoA level 55 or higher when you are pugging.
Even on my rogue at 440 iLVL with all PVE rank 3 essences in a guild run of around the same players we struggle to time a +15.
Now before you say it, if you are going to say it, like a lot of people here on the forums, timing a +15 according to sites that list times of runs, is top two percentile of all runs so far this season.
TWO PERCENT.
You need to be in a run that ranks top 2% in the entirety of all M+ runs to be able to time a +15. I get it, some people find +15’s easy at my iLVL, some people have no issues and come here acting all high and mighty and trying to talk down players like me and saying how bad I am.
But just because some find it easy does not mean we are all top 2% capable.
~60,000 runs are timed for a +15 TOTAL out of 2.9 MILLION runs ranked so far.
Now think about how it is for someone at 415 iLVL, it’s in the same boat, trying to time a +10 will be just as hard, you need to see it not from the top, but from the bottom up. There are a ton more bad players than there are good. But let me reword that, there are very few players who sit in the top echelon of wow players that they forget just how average the average player is.
So if you want to pug, you need iLVL, you need essences. Even trying for guild runs, you unless it is an east week and this week is certainly not easy, you need gear.