Sally Whitemane over Thoras Trollbane?

Why the heck would the Knights of the Ebon Blade send Sally Whitemane to the Alliance instead of Thoras Trollbane?

Nazgrim to the Horde makes total sense. Considered honorable by the faction, fought for them in Pandaria, died a warrior’s death during the rebellion, even if he was on the wrong side of it.

Trollbane was an Alliance war hero, lead a kingdom that is in the Alliance, and has a living family member in Alliance leadership.

Whitemane led an organization that was largely unaffiliated with the Alliance and doesn’t really have any connection to the organization.

I just don’t understand, from a story perspective, why they’d pick Whitemane?

18 Likes

Frankly, it’s probably just that she’s a more recognizable character. Almost every WoW player who’se been around for a while remembers Scarlet Monastery.

17 Likes

I get that aspect of it, but storywise it bugs me.

10 Likes

She’s a crack up in HotS so she’s definitely the more recognisable character. Sex appeal probably applies too.

6 Likes

Thoras Trollbane would have been more fitting, especially considering the Alliance restored Stromgarde.

8 Likes

Honestly? Considering most of the Alliance’s attitude toward the undead, sending one of their greatest heroes back to them dead might actually come off as insulting and blasphemous rather than encouraging.

With Whitemane, she’s former Alliance, but kind of a **** whose organization ended up turning against the Alliance, so her showing up as a walking corpse would probably upset fewer people.

4 Likes

You know well that isnt the real reason

No dude I mean her first appearance before raising into undeath

Dont kid yourself you know there is market for that, undead just added to her sex appeal.

I don’t think Danath or the Alliance would be thrilled to see one their heroes became undead.

3 Likes

Wasn’t she a kid in Southsore(?) before cata. It’s a gesture towards classic players.

No she was the final Scarlet Cathedral boss in Classic, she was a kid in Southshore during the Durnholde Keep caverns of time dungeon.

8 Likes

I stand corrected then.

Nilocor: I want to know the In-Story Reason for Whitemane being chosen instead of Trollbane.

In-Story Reason: There is no In Story Reason, there is only the The BFA Writers Going DERP Again.

Nilocor: Oh, The BFA Writers Going DERP Again, you old nut, now c’mon, I wanna In-Story Reason, an In-Story Reason, please.

In-Story Reason: (deep demonic voice) There is no In-Story Reason, there is only The BFA Writers Going DERP Again.

6 Likes

Especially not Turalyon. He still remembers the dude.

Although with his whole met up with Faol maybe his stance would have change. Who knows.

I mean, a few people have already put forward a perfectly reasonable in-story reason. Thoras, by virtue of being the more familiar person, would actually have been unsettling to see as Undead.

What I really wanna know is why they gave Whitemane that horrible busted hairstyle after she turned undead. She went from looking ALL done up, blood red eleganza, pointed middle fringe sharp enough to blind an orphan, SNATCHED tabard/no pants combo to make Valeera gag, to just…my hairstyle from fifth grade, a full-set transmog, and the DK trial sword.

https://blizzardwatch.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/07/Whitemane-Header-HotS.jpg

https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/wowpedia/images/2/26/High_Inquisitor_Whitemane_Legion.jpg/revision/latest/scale-to-width-down/481?cb=20170909025813

Seriously, her chapeau couldn’t have been doing that much work, could it?

10 Likes

I see the point some people have brought up that perhaps seeing Thoras as an undead might be upsetting, but the knights come to Stormwind representing the kingdom’s former regent leader, who, after being burned alive, has been serving as the full-on lich king for the past few years.

They’re also in the middle of a mass scourge invasion, in which shambling corpses are attacking their towns and homes.

I think the whole “Upsetting to see” bandaid has been effectively ripped off lol.

2 Likes

DK Whitemane has no sex appeal tho.

Neither should Sylvanas did that stop a legion of thirsty fanboys/girls from lusting after her for over a decade?