So, I came to a conclusion
1 - The ORIGINAL materials you used to the initial craft can be changed when you recraft
2 - You can change about 1/3 of all used materials by recrafting an item
3 - The game takes this “exchange” into account, kinda crafting a new item with the replaced materials + old materials
4 - It took me three recrafts to change my item to rank 5
It kinda makes sense now why it behaved this way
“/a/EFyXTpG” is the imgur link with proof of it