Raptor Mastery - Did not get item reward

I completed the Raptor Mastery quest with 1 party member and upon turn in, I did not get the item. I have screenshots to prove so, but I’m not sure how to share them.

The quest was not one where I had to select a reward from multiple options, and I am sure I did not accidentally sell the item.

I ran into this issue at 2020-10-31T08:00:00Z