Every time I try to path past a pack of soothed mobs with my prot pally, they unsoothe and are aggroed. I don’t have blessed hammer up. I can’t find any talent or spell that could be causing this, is this a bug?
Probably because paladin is too shinny ? Kidding, you might have come too close too soothed mobs. Or there was a mob with stealth detection, these mobs can’t be soothed. Also there are only certain types of NPCs that can be soothed, iirc, they are dragonkin, and humanoid.