Prot covenant

Hi fellow warriors just a quick question am I gimping myself not going kyrian? I kind of wanted to go night fae but if kyr is better I’d rather do that.

Night Fae has a great skill with ancient aftershock If that is the one you want. It is a great skill. Nice for tanking because of how strong of an AoE effect is. You won’t be disappointed.

These numbers look completely reasonable and balanced for all classes. I guess on the bright side, you’re not alone, but you would be in the minority.

I’d strongly suggest going Kyrian unless they look at these numbers and do something reflexive.

Blood Death Knight

Covenant Amount Percentage
Venthyr 23,863 50.36%
Necrolord 10,962 23.13%
Kyrian 9,138 19.29%
Night Fae 3,420 7.22%

Vengeance Demon Hunter

Covenant Amount Percentage
Kyrian 39,997 75.35%
Venthyr 8,404 15.83%
Night Fae 3,605 6.79%
Necrolord 1,073 2.02%

Guardian Druid

Covenant Amount Percentage
Night Fae 21,523 48.07%
Kyrian 12,218 27.29%
Necrolord 6,437 14.38%
Venthyr 4,596 10.26%

Brewmaster Monk

Covenant Amount Percentage
Kyrian 14,312 46.01%
Necrolord 8,720 28.03%
Night Fae 7,301 23.47%
Venthyr 775 2.49%

Protection Paladin

Covenant Amount Percentage
Kyrian 64,910 77.44%
Venthyr 14,419 17.20%
Night Fae 2,298 2.74%
Necrolord 2,191 2.61%

Protection Warrior

Covenant Amount Percentage
Kyrian 13,896 57.98%
Venthyr 4,391 18.32%
Night Fae 3,590 14.98%
Necrolord 2,090 8.72%

The real question is how do you like to play?

Honestly if you want to go Night Fae, you’ll be fine to do so unless you’re going to be focusing solely on high end (Mythic) raiding. In fact, they do well in dungeons where the aftershock can be used to its full effect. Bleeding edge keys might be tricky since you’ll need to move so much that the shock might get wasted.

In a raid situation you’ll get less rage regeneration, but if you’re only doing heroic raiding or lower this is a moot point and you should play what you want. I went Kyrian myself not only because the ability best suited my play style, but because I preferred the aesthetics of the covenant over Night Fae.

I hated the Spear, I find Ancient Aftershock amazing.

I went Venthyr because it makes Execute better for Prot/Fury and the teleport is useful for exploring and shortcuts (it can do some things Heroic Leap can’t). For Arms “mains” you’re better off picking Spear or Aftershock.

Necrolord feels thrown together at the last minute and unacceptable. It needs reworked plain and simple. Fleshcraft and boots for my troll/zandalar isn’t enough to make me pick it. DKs got an amazing ability for Necro that makes it tempting to pick over mobility options from Venthyr and Night Fae.