If your honest argument is that Sin is “fine”, you have zero credibility and everyone who plays it knows you’re fraudulent.
I have done 20+ keys as Sin. I also killed Mythic Razz as Sin. It’s fine for that content, not the best, but its fine. You on the other hand hides behind an alt.
I can tell you what I think is the actual problem of the spec, but I think I will be wasting my breath on you, ironically being the most fraudulent and full of poster here.
Do you have someone you can talk to about your feelings when you get upset? Do you need to call them?
I miss the classic wotlk assassin rogue. Mutilate->envenom just felt very satisfying. I left after original wotlk. Came back for shadowlands to find my beloved assassin rogue was replaced by this weird poison/dot class. Moved over to sub where I have been ever since though I don’t enjoy sub nearly as much as my old rogue.
I find I need to play perfectly and use my entire keyboard just to barely do as much as my ret pally with its 7 button rotation
Didn’t get this notification because I name changed lol. I was a huge combat fan. But I did both Sin and Combat through the years. When combat turned into outlaw then I went full time sin. Even the xpacs where sin was terrible like in SL, I stuck with it. I gave sub a try and the play style just isn’t my thing. So I decided to make the best of what I got. I ended up going back to sin in the latter half of S4 and nabbed top 100 world Sin. I was still capped at level 21+ keys.
Side note, do you remember the honor among thieves talent bug back in Wrath? Basically if you had multiple rogues in the same group with the talent you would get a combo point per rogue per crit. We never killed Maly faster before that was patched. Instant and constant 5 combo points/ never ending finishers. Good times.
No, they’re telling you to reroll entirely.