Player Created Items no longer say who made them in the tooltip?

This is a huge disappointment that you did this Blizz. I used to keep some items that my wife made back when she played WoW, little keepsake things, and now they no longer say that her character made them.

Why would you do this? What was the harm in saying who made the item? Really disappointing. You keep taking the humanity out of this game, and it keeps feeling less and less personal.

12 Likes

People asked for it. They didn’t want to see “Crafted by Poohead” on their gear.

I think there should just be a way to erase it, as an option.

27 Likes

If this isn’t a bug (which I sincerely hope it is), I think in the very, very, VERY odd occasion that some player gets angry about a name on a tooltip on a piece of gear they hover over maybe once a day/week - that you could perhaps implement a way to erase it.

I’ve never seen anyone complain about a name appearing on a piece of gear that has been crafted for them. Plus you can CHOOSE who crafts your gear! The only way a potential ‘silly’ name could appear on your gear is if you use the Public Order system and even then who the hell cares?

You’ve probably bought materials from Turdburger.
You’ve probably made items for Bumsniffer.
You’ve probably done a PUG group with Titwizard.
And you constantly are surrounded by weird player names in Valdrakken.

Give me back my names Blizzard! I’ve stopped crafting until you do!

2 Likes

I’m not entirely sure “who” these people are you refer to. I’ve never seen this complaint, either on the forums or from the people I play the game with. Literally never.

EDIT: From a somewhat more serious standpoint, economically the “crafted by x” was a great thing for crafters on servers that aren’t Illidan/Stormrage/Area 52 etc because it let the person know they could probably go back to you for re-crafts (or remind them who did it to begin with, if they forgot). That is now gone.

6 Likes

I noticed this the other day and assumed it was a bug.

I’d have preferred it just remain but players have the option of hiding it.

2 Likes

snickers

8 Likes

Go do a search during SL on these forums for all of the complaints about how their legendaries kept the “crafted by” on the tooltip and we kept telling them to ignore it, because it wasn’t a big deal.

It’s entirely possible it’s a bug, but
 I don’t know. I see there is a thread in Bug Reports, so that’s good.

2 Likes

Agreed. Removing name should be an option so the player can decide.

9 Likes

Gobble gobble!

I am personally not a fan of seeing who crafted my items or bags and this was prior to dragonflight. But I appreciate both sides and believe it should be on by default with an option to opt out.

6 Likes

Only reasoning they could have for doing this is because of random character named “PoopyHead” or some other “offensive” name making items.

That was Shadowlands, in a far different crafting environment. It is extremely valuable to players to know who they can contact to upgrade their armor/weapons (as recrafts can only be done through Personal orders), especially for rarer items. Word of mouth makes discovery of crafters easier as well.

Personally I just think if you have an offensive name attached to a piece of gear you obtained through a Public Order, the correct course of action would be to report that player so their name gets changed.

You’ll keep my name on your gear won’t you? <3

I never said it wasn’t. I was just giving a reason why they might have done it if it’s not a bug. That’s all.

That doesn’t change what’s on the gear. Thus, why I said it should just be an option for someone to erase it.

I haven’t had a single piece crafted since dragon flight cause the system is overwhelming and confusing but if it had your name on it then sure cause we’re friends :slight_smile:

Make it a rogue skill or something to scratch off the “serial number” so you can’t see the item’s origin.

Sad to see it’s gone without any option to keep it.

6 Likes

I agree it should be an option for people who want to keep it. But if this isn’t a bug but an intended change I’m good with that too. I always wished there was a way to remove “Crafted by”.

1 Like

That’s a great idea!

1 Like

Thats nice i dont want someones elses name on my items

2 Likes

When I am buying crafted gear for myself, I do admit people with stupid names often don’t get the sale unless they are severely undercutting the next lowest in price. That said, I have never heard anyone complain about this either.

Keep in mind, however, it has always been a case that items will lose their “crafted by” note if the crafter does any of the following:

Transfers off the server (definitely)
Stops playing long enough their name is taken by someone else (definitely)
Changes their name (I think, not 100% sure)
Changes faction (I think, not 100% sure)

It’s super sad to me, I had items crafted by friends which lost their “crafted by” note several years after the friend stopped playing. (Since I knew the people, I knew for sure they had stopped playing.) But it’s been a thing since forever.

1 Like

New idea, inscription skill to remove it (that prof really needs some love I think?).

AND players can add unlockable tooltip customizations to their weapon that are compoundable e.g. “Wielder of this blade felled Guldan, and also mastered the two step at the Darkmoon Faire” that scribes can etch into the weapon.

4 Likes