Think hard about this.
Think about the one recipe in game you would like to try IRL.
Feasts count aswell.
This one ofc:
crunchy spider surprise and an ice cold glass of kungaloosh
whatever the spiciest ialian/indian fish dish is.
Something involving Mystery Meat, because it would help a whole lot with my freezer.
I’d really want to try some conjured mana buns, or something made from pure arcane. I can get most any wacky, carbon-based food here on Earth. But give me some of that magic stuff!
Mulgore Spice Bread always sounded nice to me.
Other than that, it’s obviously a favorite of mine:
There’s an actual World of Warcraft Cookbook with really good recipes.
Particularly, the recipe for Dragonbreath Chili, it’s awesome, though I’d recommend to go lighter on the cinnamon and skip the grated cheese (just add cheese on the side, to individual bowl at discretion), the “heat” (spice-iness) might require some adjustment based on preference. Actually going to make a big vat of it this weekend. The best chili ever - but it doesn’t actually have a proc to belch flame.