On the Jewishness of the Draenei

It’s well-known by now that the primary inspiration for the Draenei is Jewish culture. However, for those who are unconvinced, I will break down the basic proof of this statement.

1: The Draenei are led by a prophet leader who led them to safety from dire circumstances. Compare Velen to Moses.
2: They came to Azeroth on a ship called the Exodar (Exodus).
3: Their history is one of constant exile and difficulty, mirroring the struggles of Jewish people.
4: Many of their names and words associated with them come from Hebrew, or other languages associated with Jewish people.

Names like ‘Inaara’ and ‘Kaalif’ and ‘Idaar’ are Arabic in origin and were commonly used by Jews under Muslim rule during the Golden Age of Islam and names like ‘Merran’ and ‘Meiri’ (that are variants of the name Miriam, one of the most important prophets in Judaism and the sister of Moses), ‘Ezekiel’ (another name of an important prophet in Judaism), Joraal (Meaning ‘God will uplift’ in Hebrew, and the name of Superman’s father, another heavily Jewish-coded character created by two Jews) and ‘Behomat’ (Behemoth in the original Hebrew pronunciation, a sea monster mentioned in the Book of Job).
(Source: http://thenaaru.tumblr.com/post/137924157177/thetomatofaerie-the-thing-that-i-love-about-the)

5: The track ‘Malach’ from the Warlords of Draenor soundtrack, which itself has a Hebrew name meaning ‘messenger’, features a nigun (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nigun) at around the 50 second mark.

With this made clear, I can now move on to the main gist of this post: some fun headcanons, and a response to a slight elephant in the room.

Headcanons:

1: While Draenei do not have surnames, they use patronymics to distinguish between themselves. For example - Inaara, whose father is named Hatan, would be known as Inaara bat Hatan, while her brother Joraal would be known as Joraal ben Hatan.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jewish_name#Surname
2: Just as Judaism (besides the incredibly tiny Karaite sect) is Rabbinic in nature (teachers of the scripture interpret matters, debate is common and encouraged), Draenei worship of the Light is heavily based on discussion and interpretation, and different Exarchs will interpret the word of a Naaru in a certain manner. Dogmatism is heavily discouraged, and worshippers are encouraged to find their own truths in the scripture (this is specifically non-Orthodox, but Draenei don’t seem Orthodox to me).
3: Similarly, the Draenei approach to the Light places next to zero importance on evangelism. This is less ‘headcanony’, as we see a very clear difference in how the humans and Draenei act in this respect. Individual draenei see the Light as immensely important to themselves, but they do not enforce their beliefs on others.
4: The Draenei use an abjad (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abjad) script, written right to left. Perhaps they even use the Hebrew script, just as Common is written in a variant of Futhark.

The elephant in the room:

With all this in mind, the recent plot developments on AU Draenor might seem at first glance to be very problematic - depicting a Jewish-coded society becoming the oppressors in a manner that might seem like a poorly constructed and offensive commentary on modern Israel. However, the manner in which the AU Draenei become so zealous and militant is through their (implied) exposure to the words of Xe’ra. Their religion shifts from culturally tied tradition to an evangelistic dogmatic belief system. There is a clear intent of conversion behind their actions.

To put it simply; there is one very clear example in history where a group of Jewish people shifted to an evangelistic and dogmatic belief system after the introduction of a perceived savior and person of great spiritual importance - Christianity.

22 Likes

This was a very well-written post that had a lot of evidence laid out, you clearly did your research. And I agree: Draenei are about as Jewish-coded as Pandaren are Chinese-coded!

That bit at the end I’ll have to think about, though. I’m not quite sure what is being implied either by you or (perhaps unintentionally) by the game’s writers here.

I though the goblins were the jewish race.

No but seriously I have no idea what you are talking about.
Half the things you say could apply to muslims too… or any religion really.
Or simply you made assertions that could apply to any other race and not at all inherently Draenei.

I think this is the classic case of already having a hypothesis and then trying to find anything remotely relevent to prove that hypothesis rather than the other way around.

Forum Moderator Note: Inflammatory comment removed.

4 Likes

I always considered the Draenei based off of the Roma people of central/eastern Europe. It does have a large mixture of Hebraic culture infused with Hindi, Islamic, and other cultures. They are sort of wandering exiles who formed their own culture as they traveled, and adapted to new lands. Just like the Draenei.

The Draenei language and dance seems to reflect on this. But you do make good points.

The Evangelism/Conversion part is the newest addition to Draenei lore and the most compelling for your argument. I never thought of it that way, but that is a good comparison.

I would have tried to work the term Hebraic in, instead of the term you used.

1 Like

I suspect this might be the type of thread to get banned.

Would it?

Does that mean a thread titled

On the Britishness of the Gilneans

On the Chinese-ness of the Pandaren

or

Oh Darkspears, Ja-maican me crazy!

would also get banned? :open_mouth:

4 Likes

Gilneans have victorian style architecture, clothing and accent.

Pandaren are so chinese themed that you would have to be from another planet to deny it.

Darkspears have jamaican accent and live in tropical locations?

These are so obviously in your face that I doubt anyone would argue.

But Draenei being jewish because they have a jewlery skill, have a prophet (muslims and other religions have one too), have rune like language (like every other race in wow) and etc…
Draenei have russian accents and an indian dance lol.
They are a melting pot of different things.

You want to draw some jewish heritage inspirations? sure. But Draenei being jewish and only jewish based on these weak arguments?
Very doubtful.

3 Likes

The Tortollans are ultra-jewish, and many have said the goblins have traits of racist Jewish caricatures.

Welcome to the וורלד אוף וורקראפט

1 Like

There is literally a track in the WoD soundtrack called ‘Messenger’ in Hebrew (Malach), which features traditional Jewish liturgical singing. They are led by a Moses figure, and literally came to Azeroth on a ship named after the Exodus. It’s not subtle, I don’t see why you’re denying it.

4 Likes

Goblins are your brooklyn stereotypes but brooklyn has been home to many jewish people so… there you go.

2 Likes

The Tortollans are essentially old Jewish grandparents, yes. That’s not exactly the same situation, though.

And goblins, historically? Yes. But Blizzard have actually made a clear effort to distinguish the WoW goblins from that history and made them into, well… Steampunk Italian-Americans.

3 Likes

And they dance to this:

Whats your point?

Dances do not show anything about actual inspiration. The kaldorei female dance is a French singer’s dance, yet they have no French inspiration. That is saved for the Shal’dorei, who were created over a decade after that dance.

2 Likes

you may be right, that the draenei are a melting pot of many cultural inspirations, but my post was meant to allay Surma’s suspicion that

I don’t think there’s anything ban-worthy of discussing the real world cultural inspirations of the wow races.

2 Likes

I could say the same exact thing on a music choice.
Not every race is 1:1 representation of a real world culture besides some exceptions like Worgen but thats only their visual theme and it does not go any deeper than that.

Newsflash. The developers use many inspirations from our real world to develop this fantasy world.
Just because Yrel went full on inquisition is not a commentary on Modern Israel and their foreign or domestic politics.
Additionally the Jewish people were not the only ones led by a prophet.
Prophet Muhammad comes to mind.

He too like Moses had many trials that could be referenced loosely in WoW.
Oh PS.

Jewish =/= Israel.
One is a religion and a people spread accross the world and the other is a country with many strengths and weakenesses.
Please do not compare Israel’s actions or critism as somehow representative of all jewish people. That is grotesquely anti-semetic; the jewish people are not some sort of hive mind monolith represented by Israel. Stop this silliness.

2 Likes

Do you want to read my post again? I literally said it’s not that, even if it might come across as that in light of the Jewish inspiration.

4 Likes

So events on AU Draenor are problematic and offensive because they present a “Jewish-coded” society as being oppressive, but in actuality it’s fine and makes sense because they’re really now “Christianity-coded”?

3 Likes

I did. But you said it is representative of catholicism rather than jewishness that you somehow linked to being representative of Israel.

You pick and choose what you like and discard anything unsavory as representative of something else.

4 Likes

Is it… Controversial to say that early Christianity was very dogmatic and evangelistic? It’s literally ancient history.

3 Likes

You mean the Scarlet Crusade?