Ok, so what's the best way to get the Horseman drops?

[Sendryn-sentinels]

@Peppermint-eldrethalas

Does having the four wickerman curses increase chances?

Yes. On first kill of the day.

@Kaivax

@Zinsus-thrall

Is there an increased chance on the first kill of the day for the headless horseman mount?

Yes, and the first drop of the day receives a bonus likelihood that scales with the number of curses you apply.