I wouldn’t say that “Wow is failing hard” but I would say that I really do not like how far WoW has shifted from High Fantasy to Anime Fantasy in just how extreme everything has become.
I get the whole “Rule of Cool” thing but I think its gone way too far. I do not like how high my character has been elevated in WoW to the point of being a literal god among men and the sole savior of Azeroth.
Personally I would like to see a return to less focus on us and more focus on the stories happening around us. To be honest, I am not massively against the well established heroes of Warcraft being powerful… but we, as players, have now bypassed Green Jesus in terms of importance and power and I just really do not like that.
It honestly makes me wonder “How long until we are just throwing galaxies around as a form of attack?” as if we are on Dragon Ball or Gurren Lagann levels of absurd power scaling.
Recently I watched the Hobbit movies for the first time (Yeah, I know, way late on that bus) but there was a scene in one of the movies where the Orcs have caught up to them and they are all stuck up in a tree trying to figure out what to do. Its at that point Gandalf starts grabbing pine cones and igniting them to basically make fireballs and that scene really stuck with me.
Throughout the movies it really sparked that feeling of a fantasy world and when seeing Gandalf’s “magic” it really stood out to me in a good way. It was not over the top and insane, it all felt grounded in some level of realism that made sense for the fantasy setting.
Warcraft use to be “grounded” as well in its own way. Obviously never that subdued but it still felt acceptable. Look at the Mage in the Vanilla intro cinematic and how he wields his magic, you can see that there is a lot of effort being put into just normal fireballs and summoning a Blizzard. Fast forward to now and we see Jaina literally levitating an entire ship, creating fake arcane cannons, all just to basically fire arcane missiles at a wall.
Its so over the top, so absurdly unnecessary that it really takes me out of the moment. Yeah, Jaina is powerful and all that and should look cool but there is a point where it goes so far into the absurd that it goes from looking cool to looking silly with how over the top and pointless it is. Not to mention you create major power scaling issues for your storyline later on where you have to make up excuses as to why all of a sudden the characters that could literally hold worlds together are struggling to fight a single orc.
I think another good example of absurdity would be comparing the 8.3 N’zoth cinematic to the Dragon Soul cinematic’s with Thrall and the Dragon Soul.
With thrall and the Dragon Soul you have a well established artifact steeped heavily in the lore and built up over years being wielded by the (at the time) strongest Shaman in the world and all the Dragon Aspects at the same time to attack Deathwing. Was it over the top? Sure. But it was far more grounded than what we have seen in 8.3 so far AND it wasn’t us the player, it was major lore characters that have been built up for YEARS doing said over the top action.
We have literally been built up to godhood now to the point that everything past this has to be cranked up to even more absurd levels to keep progressing. How are we expected to believe that we would ever struggle with killing Kobolds again after this?
Not only are power scaling out of control with in game equipment but the writing is also out of control with how powerful we have become in such a short period and it fluctuates all over the place! One moment we are death beaming N’zoth, the next we are struggling to kill Wendigo’s or something.
I know Green Jesus was criticized majorly for being so absurdly powerful and important but its even more absurd that we are so powerful and important. I want to go back to the story being about the World and its Characters and helping them as a no-named adventurer instead of being the literal god that even major NPC’s look up to as the savior, the Champion of Azeroth!
Idk, just my two cents. WoW needs to be grounded again. Of course, things can change and nothing about 8.3 is final but my statement is more or less a broad opinion of WoW’s current story.