I have spent many moons planning a system like this for my own game. I’d like to share a bit of why I believe this could be a positive change for the game and community. 99% of you wont read this, but still, this is for you 1% that actually care to provide or read constructive feedback and suggestions:
Increased Accessibility
Allowing players to queue for higher-tier content makes these experiences available to those who might not have a regular group or the time to manually form one. This inclusivity can enrich the game for a wider audience.
Skill Based Matchmaking
By utilizing players combat data, comparing performance metrics with others of the same class and specialization, Blizzard could intelligently determine a player’s readiness for harder content. This ensures that players are matched with others of similar skill levels, leading to more balanced and enjoyable group experiences.
Enhanced Learning Opportunities
Being able to queue for challenging content provides a platform for players to learn and improve in a real game environment. This hands on experience can be invaluable for mastering mechanics and refining skills.
Community Building
An intelligent matchmaking system can foster new connections between players who might not have met otherwise. This could lead to the formation of new friendships, guilds, and a stronger overall community. More about this later on…
Reduced Gatekeeping
Automating the entry process can help minimize gatekeeping behaviors that sometimes occur in manual group formations. This promotes a more welcoming environment for all players eager to tackle end-game challenges.
Motivation to Improve
Knowing that performance impacts matchmaking could encourage players to invest time in improving their gameplay. This not only benefits individual players but also elevates the overall skill level within the community.
Time Efficiency
Streamlining the process of joining end-game content means less time waiting and more time playing. For those with limited gaming hours, this can make a significant difference in their overall experience.
Potential Implementation Considerations
Performance Metrics
The system could assess factors like damage output, healing efficiency, combat activity time, and mechanics execution (these are just a few examples) to ensure players meet the necessary thresholds for higher tier content. Machine learning is the key to making this system effective.
Progressive Unlocking
Players might unlock the ability to queue for more difficult content as they demonstrate proficiency in preceding levels (e.g., completing Normal before queuing for Heroic).
I understand that some players worry that introducing a queue system for high end content could diminish the sense of community by reducing the need for manual group formation. However, I believe that, if implemented thoughtfully, this system can actually enhance community interaction in several meaningful ways:
Bridging Social Gaps
- Inclusivity for All Players: An intelligent matchmaking system can bring together players who might not have the opportunity to connect otherwise, such as those from smaller servers, different time zones, or with irregular play schedules.
- Lowering Barriers to Entry: By reducing the intimidation factor of joining high end content, more players may feel encouraged to participate, thereby expanding the community of active end game participants.
Fostering New Relationships
- Shared Challenges Create Bonds: Overcoming difficult content together can form strong connections between players. These shared experiences often lead to lasting friendships and even new guild formations.
- Diverse Interactions: Automated matchmaking introduces players to a wider variety of individuals, promoting variety within social circles and preventing echo chambers.
Encouraging Communication and Teamwork
- Necessity of Coordination: High end content requires strategy and communication. Even in an LFG setting, players will need to discuss tactics and roles, fostering teamwork and collaboration.
- Opportunities for Leadership: Players can sign up to lead their groups, promoting leadership skills and enhancing group cohesion.
Complementing Existing Communities
- Supplement, Not Replace: The LFG system can coexist with traditional group formations. Guilds and manual groups will still play a crucial role for those who prefer that method.
- Flexibility for Players: It provides an alternative for players who can’t commit to regular raid schedules but still wish to engage with the community and high end content.
Reducing Toxic Gatekeeping:
- Minimizing Elitism: By automating the entry process based on skill metrics, we can reduce instances where players are unfairly excluded due to subjective criteria.
- Promoting a Welcoming Environment: A more open system encourages a culture of inclusivity, making new and returning players feel more accepted.
Enhancing Learning Opportunities:
- Mentorship Potential: Experienced players matched with less experienced ones can lead to mentorship relationships, where knowledge and strategies are shared.
- Community Growth: As more players become proficient, the overall skill level of the community rises, benefiting everyone involved.
Encouraging Positive Behavior
- Reputation Systems: Incorporating player feedback into matchmaking can encourage positive behavior, as players strive to maintain good standings. Other games have incorporated similar systems successfully.
- Shared Accountability: Knowing that performance and behavior impact matchmaking can motivate players to contribute positively to group dynamics.
Addressing Concerns
- Fear of Anonymity Reducing Accountability: While it’s true that anonymity can sometimes lead to negative behavior, an intelligent system can include checks and balances, such as tracking player reports and commendations to promote accountability.
- Loss of Tight Knit Groups: The option to queue doesn’t eliminate the ability to form manual groups. Players who value close-knit teams can continue to play as they prefer.
My Closing Note:
I don’t know about you, but every time I find myself most attached to this game, or considering stepping away, it’s always been strongly tied to my level of community involvement. When I’m engaged with others, tackling challenges side by side, and feeling that sense of camaraderie, the game transcends being just a hobby; it becomes a shared adventure. By building systems that grow the community in positive ways, like an intelligent LFG system, we’re not just enhancing our individual experiences but also contributing to a richer, more connected world for everyone. In the long run, fostering a vibrant, welcoming and growing community is a net positive for the game we all love.
