I did not get this toy on my main after getting level 6 rep with the Loamm. In addition, none of my alts are even offered the reward when they hit renown 6, the quest just offers the other two rewards. I’ve gone through this on at least 5 alts with no luck. I’ve also submitted reports in game, but they just give me the runaround and tell me to submit a bug report.
have you done the quest
?