New Torghast is objectively worse

The timer is NOT required for scoring high. Clearing 100% is insufficient. It sucks that Blizzard didn’t explain the scoring in-game, but the “arbitrary things” are fully explained in the WoWhead Scoring Article. Or you could just play how you like and ignore the score–you don’t need it to complete the run if soul cinders are what’s most important to you.

5-Star Run with Near-Zero Time Score