I dont know why this hasnt been reported yet, but you cant track all the individual squirrels for the 4 new achievements added in 9.0. I dont believe this is intended since the older squirrel achievements showed tracking.
i already told them of a bug for the To all the squirrels i set sail to see- that is around 3 weeks ago if not more - not working yet checked today for the 10th time
Go to wowhead and look them up to see what you need to /love for them.
i did and i made a macro too - i get all of them but no achievement . tried ALSO without macro
You may have used /love on the combat version of the pets that often times can have the same name nearby the non-combat ones. I completed all of these a few days ago and they worked ok.
I agree that not being able to properly track which critters have been completed in-game is an unnecessary pain…
This issue has been corrected for patch 9.0.2.
i checked each pne and made sure they were critters and not combat pets and did it yesterday and didnt get the achiev
made it at last i went around zuldazar al /love all the critters i needed there in the last one was the one i got the achiev