I like the SL dungeons we have, but eight dungeons get old really fast as we’ve seen. I think most people agree that BFA mythic+ dungeons were good, but now they are not being used anymore, which is a shame.
I propose we should allow BFA & Legion m+ dungeons to scale with us. I don’t see the problem with that loot still being relevant as well. Maybe change the items like geti’ikku, so they don’t continue to be BIS for everything.
It’s a waste not to use the Legion & BFA m+ anymore. Blizzard is throwing away old content. We would have something close to 30 dungeons with BFA, Legion, and SL. That would be so much more content to do.
I am not entirely sure how key’s would work. Trying to get a particular key out of 30dungeons could be quite difficult. This RNG factor would need to be figured out.
Don’t need to bring mythic key stone achievement back or anything for each expac.
Let me know what you everyone thinks.
6 Likes
For the RNG Issue make it where each key has 3 options so you can either go to a Legion dungeon, BFA dungeon, or a Shadowlands dungeon giving you the option to just keep to shadowlands dungeons, There would still be RNG involved but it wouldn’t be as harsh! It would also make it more enjoyable for the players because say you get a shadowlands dungeon that you don’t like on that key BUT there is a legion dungeon that that you really enjoy. It would be a great use of old content and make everything all around more thrilling.
I ran thousands of mythics in BfA. Literally thousands. I don’t have any desire to go back there any time soon. Just my personal feelings on the subject.
I think this is where Carrll’s idea comes in to save the day! Giving an option of 3 dungeons, 1 from each expac, on 1 key could help greatly.
Could be BIG! I would love to go do Legion mythic+ and freehold again as well.
Understandable but add my reply to his post and it makes it better, giving the player the option to pick between a legion, bfa, or a shadowlands dungeon changing your options every time you completed a key
No, no, no, no, no. I don’t want to see SOTS again.
That’s the point of having 3 options on 1 key. You don’t need to ever do SOTS again because you have 1 legion/BFA/SL dungeon to choose.
This would stop harder dungeons from being reasonable because people would always choose the easiest dungeons to run.
It also open the door to lazy dungeon design in the future.
Also also, the whole point of having these dungeons all expansions on mythic + is to allow players to fully optimize their set up and route so that eventually the dungeon can be done to perfection and this option makes that so much harder with us having to find optimal set ups and routes for 30+ dungeons
This will never happen… not only would balancing around 30 dungeons be an absolute time-consuming and confusing nightmare, but who the hell wants to go back to dungeons we just spent +2 years doing? Even worse, imagine how hard it would be for people to learn routes for that many dungeons… pugging would be impossible or unsuccessful most of the time. I started leveling in BFA dungeons with a new toon and people are screwing up normal dungeon mechanics… I couldn’t imagine going back and doing everything again with players that haven’t seen the content.
I’d rather see Timewalking dungeons be able to be done on M+, but even that’s a stretch.
Dungeons aren’t being wasted, they’re unused and there’s a big difference.
Make them available for m+ during timewalking weeks.
It is a neat idea but i know i will never go back to BFA dungeons ever. Most of them were trash in my opinion and that expansion burned out my desire to play the game and even killed my former guilds. Plus what others have said it would be impossible to balance it all.
You all gotta BELIEVE in Blizzard! Having 30 different mythic+ dungeons would be BIG!
Blizzard is doing good lately! They even made MW monk good again!
obviously it will never happen. and it something that you would have a choice on if it did happen if you understood correctly, on top of that i think many people will agree that unused content is wasted content. Remember you would have a choice on whether or not you want to do a legion keystone, bfa, or even just a shadowlands, they can spend their time doing that instead of making a silly store mount, I’m sure it’s easier to balance content than to make a new mount
As someone who has been around for all of that content, I would say that it’s old content to me. I spent 2 years doing that same content. I don’t want to revisit that content until it’s nostalgic and even then in small doses. If you told me that I was going to have to do BFA dungeons again, I would seriously re-consider doing dungeons. I’m over them. Plus, it would be insanely hard to find groups with so many different choices of dungeons to do. It would be a complete disaster from a pugging perspective.
I would highly disagree with this… because adding more dungeons increases the amount of consideration that they are putting in when making decisions. Plus, most of these dungeons are created based on power levels of those expansions. So they would have to re-work many of these to make sense with the current content and scale correctly. It would be a huge project with a lot of ambiguous areas to clear up.
I love old dungeons but I think making all of them M+ compliant would be an issue.
What I would like to see instead is Timewalking being a permanent, always available option, with a different 4-6 dungeons each week (from any expansion, maybe 1 dungeon from each expansion).
But it would not be too big to be considered as a .5 patch, and yes while it would be a bad for pugging it would force players to go ahead and join a guild and build a community which if you have friends you know that isn’t a bad thing, and if you don’t want to do the content then you would simply stay with shadowlands keys, overall we both know it will never happen because blizz is too busy being bad at balancing our classes atm but the idea doesn’t hurt or harm anyone, it’s simply flavor for people that loved bfa and legion keys, come on you know you would enjoy going back to upper kara on a 15 getting to that last boss with 6 minutes left in your either bad pug or good guild and get that key timed.
this is a good idea. let us have a random pile 8 per week rather than just the SL 8.
they are basically PVE arenas, why not?
are you saying you like an easy game? and they already are lazy adding 1 dungeon to an expac like they did in bfa and splitting it is lazy where as in legion yes they did do that but they still had 2 dungeons afterwards