At some point, on this toon I completed the quest called Tiger Mastery. It was probably back when hunters wore leather until level 40, but I am not certain. This is my only toon that has completed the quest (I checked them all).
On this toon I have the appearance for the mail feet, Footpads of Sin’Dall. On my leather-wearing toons I have the appearance for the leather feet, Paws of Sin’Dall.
My clothie toon would very much like to use the appearance of the cloth vest reward from the quest, Cat Lover’s Vest. But it is not available in her collection. It shows it is available from a “quest” (it’s this one), and indeed my clothie never did the quest.
I thought that when we completed a quest on one toon, our account got the appearances of all the rewards for that quest, even if the toon that completed the quest was the wrong class to use a particular reward; was I confused about that? If so, then answer me this: my mace-wielding toons have the appearance for Sin’Dall’s Femur. My hunter can’t use that appearance, so why did my mace-wielding toons get the appearance?