I loved the feeling that you had to be prepared to go and quest, or go on any journey for that matter. Just walking outside without planning a bit did not work.
As a hunter I needed ammo, food and drink for me, food for my pet, potions, etc. Bag space was much more limited and you had to really plan your route as well.
And then on your journey, searching and exploring along the way to gather herbs and ores. They didn’t show up on your mini map, you had to find them all visually. Made each find a real success.
It is really the little things that made Vanilla so awesome.
What I loved about vanilla that every expansion has gotten farther and farther away from is the class fantasy. Your rogue had to learn to make poisons and you had to keep in stock or risk running out. Hunter is the big one, where so much of your time is spent keeping your pet happy, leveling it, making or buying ammo. All of that is gone. Needing reagents to cast spells. Your mage jumps off the cliff, oh crap no light feathers!
I guess it comes down to the point that there really wasn’t any instant gratification in vanilla. You had to work for everything and that gave a sense of meaning and accomplishment. And that’s what I miss that retail fails hard on.
So folks in this thread don’t want more portals? Personally I did enjoy this aspect as well for the reasons you mentioned. I don’t know if the ocean drops will still happen in Classic though
Another thing I did like was attunements. I enjoy questing and so those felt like epic quests to push through, and help others with.
I liked the stuff that made it feel like you were in a proper fantasy world.
Building a campfire required wood. Firing a bow required arrows, which was faster if you had a quiver equipped. Hunters needed to feed and generally care for their pets because it was a bond. Spells took reagents.
Thank you for posting this. Especially the part about the attunement. Its hard at times to look past the Blue part of your posts sometimes and remember you’re players just like us.
Can’t wait for the great epic jail break chain myself!
I’ve already had to sit down and re-plan my attunements, not just Onyxia and Molten Core, but the Stratholme Key, Seal of Ascension, Scarlet Monastery Key, Dire Maul Key.
Getting access to these places through quest chains always felt far more epic than “Hit Join in the LFR interface”.