First off, I want to save great work Blizzard on bringing back dedicated PVP CC breaker trinkets. I think this is a great move towards fixing some critical failures in the current PVP system.
Now onto the race dilemma, if you can call it that.
BLUF/TLDR: I believe that racials play too high of a role in rated PVP, to the point where the player feels like they are shooting themselves in the foot by not playing some specific classes. Below I will detail data pulled from arenamate which draws all information directly from the wow armory ratings page.
When you look that Duelist and above brackets (2100+), you will notice a very common denominator between Alliance and Horde. That is 1 race of each faction dominating for the bulk of classes.
When you sort by race in this bracket, you see Orc and Human on top. Combined they make up 52% of all races in the bracket. Over half.
Now if you look into this deeper, and sort by just the classes that the ORC can play, they now bump up to 74.2% of characters on the horde.
Humans with this same metric are at 69.6%. I high anticipate this number to rise in shadowlands as well based off their racial ability and the return of pvp cc breaker trinkets.
Below I will link the base line statistics by faction, without looking at the classes they cannot play.
ALLIANCE:
Human: 57.8%
Night Elf: 26.2%
Dwarf: 4%
Void Elf: 3.7%
Dark Iron Dwarf: 3.3%
Gnome: 2.2%
Draenei: 1.1%
Kul Tiran: .4%
Mechagnome: .4%
Panda: .4%
Worgen: .3%
Lightforged Dranei: .2%
HORDE
Orc: 48.5%
Blood Elf: 21.7%
Undead: 10.5%
Tauren: 6.3%
Troll: 5.8%
Goblin: 2.5%
Zandalari Troll: 1.7%
Panda: 1.3%
Vupera: .6%
Highmountain Tauren: .5%
Nightborne: .3%
Mag’Har Orc: .3%
With this information above, I believe that we can make some real positive changes by fine tuning, or even removing combat specific racials for classes. That should allow us the realign these numbers to match up with what people actually want to play for lore and cosmetic reasons, and not for their PVP racials.
Please let me know what you as the community thinks.
Thanks.