I am in a raiding guild for Classic Fresh. We raid MC the guild leader takes all of the matts, BoE’s and puts it to the AH and says “its for the guild”. He says its to help tanks but I found out they only receive 100g. The rest of the DPS get nothing. Not sure about the healers.
To attend raid we are required to bring flasks. Is this regular for classic fresh guilds? Or is my guild in the wrong?
He said he was going to buy ony cloaks for everyone. But the post is deleted in the discord. Now I don’t know.
guild taking mats is normal 
they go to the guild bank
BoEs tend to be rolled on in my experience
requiring flasks in MC is a red flag, unless you seriously want to be a parse lord
and guilds should supply everyone with an ony cloak, yes, what else are they doing with their ony scales?
hth
2 Likes
Nah ur GM is scummy. Tanks normally get first pick of gear in classic raids then ur DPS fight over everything else while healers kinda just get the healer items. Heals are the least important to gear in classic content. That mats being sold are not a bad thing, but do the math. If he’s selling 200g of mats and thats going to tanks sure. If he’s selling 500g of mats and only 200g going to tanks idk man. That’s scummy.
1 Like
Unless its done with total transparency you’re being gamed.
4 Likes
Ah okay. Yeah he says it goes to the guild bank. But none of us has seen any of it.
The BoE’s are going to the guild bank. Yeah, I hope the ony cloaks are going to the guild.
Ignore eyr. He’s a clown he plays era only and thinks SoM is the hardest version of the game. Just ask ur GM for pics of the gbank character.
5 Likes
What kind of transparency?
Eastcoast - Yeah, I tried. But usually its ignored. Asked officers too but its ignored too.
There’s more than one way but an example would be a guild accessible google sheets spreadsheet linked in your discord showing what materials were obtained, how much of them there are, where they are stored, where they are going/whats happening to them etc etc.
If theyre being sold, how many, how much and where that gold is going and/or how much of it is being stockpiled and so on.
He doesn’t do spreadsheets. Basically what is said is “goes to the guild bank”
That a red flag?
Do you know what kind of resist sets are needed by tanks in bwl?
Does DPS even need ony cloak? Or can they just stand behind the throne?
Well like Eastcoast said, if the GM is not linking screenshots of the Guild Bank toon and explaining whats going on with it then you’re probably being used in some way.
It doesnt have to be a spreadsheet. It can be screenshots and explanatory posts with clear evidence you’re not being BS’d.
2 Likes
You don’t need FR for firemaw. He just falls over.
the throne thing was always an exploit so who knows they could have fixed it
I was the guild banker in my 2019 guild, I had a spreadsheet and a discord channel dedicated to it, people could see where stuff went and when and could ask to have mats for crafts.
Keeping that secret with a ‘just trust me bro’ attitude is dubious, guild mates should at least know how many raid mats are available to use.
Edit: I became the banker after the previous GM who quit gave away all our ingots to another guild without telling anyone, and the person who got them transferred off the server without paying anyone back lol.
here is the truth about classic 60.
1- one player create a guild
2- spam chat to get many players
3- raid molten core raid which is joke raid
4- take all boe’s
5- sell those boe’s for thousands of gold
6- sell that gold for tons of $$$
7- they can make approximately 6k USD in the first 4months
8- fail in next tier raid but still run the guild as long as he earn $$ from mc or zg/aq20
9- later at some point the GM disband the guild or leave to join another guild
10- this happened many times in 2019 and still happening so welcome to classic 60.
1 Like