Is it possible to make any gold with Leatherworking?

Hello,

I picked up leatherworking and jewelcrafting to be able to easily craft and recraft my PVP gear.

I thought I could try to make some gold now that I have professions anyway.

With jewelcrafting, every morning I can create a 3-star gem with concentration from 2-star materials, and get a few hundred gold to cover the bills. Nothing crazy, but is some low passive gold income.

With leatherworking however, it’s a different story - no matter what I craft, even after I put concentration, the resulting 3-star item barely covers the materials, if at all.

Am I missing something? Is there really no way to make even 200-300 gold a day with leatherworking?

Thanks

there’s no benefit to crafting your own gear other than not feeling obligated to tip on a work order.

its the biggest fallacy of this new crafting system. I just go alchemy for the double flask duration and engineering for the Jeeves/wormholes on every single character and its 10x the benefit of a crafting profession to craft my own gear.

at this stage of a patch the only ways to make gold are to have 5 alts constantly spamming trade chat and whispering anyone who needs something you have, or farming raw mats and converting them into flasks/consumables. in many cases you lose gold if you buy raw mats and craft them into weapon stones/flasks/pots

1 Like

Make a spreadsheet and do the math. Let go of the doom and gloom and do the math. We are at the end of a season at the moment, but comes S2 and new sparks, everyone will need recrafts. New raid means consumables will be in demand. Embellish that are recommended are subject to change also, keep an eye on that. It is a bit of a lull at the moment, but it should pick up.

We’re just in a really sucky lull right now that should ease when next season hits. I’m feeling it myself. Keep pegging away at it man, stash some mats, bank up them knowledge points to expand your trees, and prepare to strike when the iron is hot when them new sparks and stuff drop. People will be lighting up trade chat looking for recrafts.

Just go alchemy/enchanting on every character. Taking a profession just to save a few thousand gold in crafting costs is cutting your own throat. Most guild crafters will do it for free anyway (everyone is maxed now). And you’ll probably need 4-5 items crafted every 6 months.

Meanwhile Alchemy/Enchanting will make you at least 5k gold every day for the entire expansion.

So LW is an extremely challenging profession to make gold on the AH. If you want to make gold with LW, the best way is to fill orders in trade for gear.

LW gear (like BS weapons or tailoring gear) is popular in terms of the number of requests made. This causes problems for reagents which are used for these popular recipes. Because people crafting these will obtain reagents for free with resourcefulness procs, their cost for “making” the reagent is zero. This weighs down the prices below the cost of actually making the reagent.

Additionally, the multicraft wheel of the “Learned Leatherworker” specialization gives extra multicraft items. This additionally weighs down the prices below the cost of making the reagent, because when you multicraft, you can multicraft a LOT.

Together, these two factors have caused the reagents to go VERY far below the cost of making the reagent to the point where you MUST multicraft or you won’t make a profit. And you can’t even use mirror powder, the margin is too tight for that.

To make sure you multicraft, you will need to make items in bulk. The problem is there isn’t the demand to sustain many people making these in bulk. (which then makes people desperate to sell, which pushes down things even further.)

Not only that, we have gloomfathom hide and profaned tinderbox in a lot of our recipes. This means that making bulk quantities of these things is extremely risky. You could end up with a stock of items which cost you tens or even hundreds of thousands of gold that just don’t sell. And just one or two resourcefulness procs on those could make or break your profit margin.

So, if you don’t have “waste not” and “industrious innovations” completed, do not attempt to enter this market.

If you’re going to ignore all my warnings so far, then here’s the safest thing: Storm-Touched Weapon Wrap. Because almost all of the weapon recipes require it, it does sell fairly quickly. It can be made at a profit without multicraft if you buy R2 reagents and use concentration. It can be sold with below average procs of multicraft with R3 reagents, but again you MUST multicraft or you will not profit (for R3). In either case the profits are slim and any shifts in the market could make this go below profit level.

Second thing you could make: green profession tools. However, these items are REALM based (commodities like ore, herbs, are REGION based, but items that can be equipped are REALM based). You will have to check with your realm prices and do the math yourself.

2 Likes

Thank you!! This was exactly the kind if explanation I was hoping for!

:bowing_man:

1 Like

Keep trucking. Keep improving leather working. Keep on doing patron orders keep getting knowledge points as often as you can. In dragon flight I didn’t make any noticeable gold with LW during season one. But all together during seasons two three and four I made about four million gold from it. I didn’t actively advertise or spend all day doing it. It just turned out specific items became BiS for all leather and mail toons.

Toxic patches and their connected embellishments. Oh dear. The second that bis list came out. Oh momma! Made a mint off those!

2 Likes

Il telling you. I kept a M0 Brackenhide lockout permanently extended and I was just raking in the gold. But even the shadow flame patches later on scored me so much gold.