I haven’t really played much of SoD, but I definitely love the idea of it. It’s cool seeing things move in a different direction, and I hope they branch it out as its own little “alternate timeline”.
One of the things I thought was super cool was them adding unique Class-quests for new items. Yet something I felt kind of undermined that, was that those same items could just be purchased from a vendor during the Anniversary event (in retail), lacking any of the flavor, and their appearances also being available to all classes, robbing them of any identity.
SoD seems to have a lot of cool armor and mount recolors, and I’m hoping I’m able to level up quickly enough to check some of those things out. If anything, I could actually see it being more motivating to be able to unlock those appearances on Retail, for continuing to play on SoD.
Conversely, I would feel a whole lot less interested in playing SoD, if the new items just continue to be ported to Retail a bit unceremoniously. “Cool stuff” has always been a major reason to push through content, and just seeing the stuff made easily attainable on retail would be a bummer.
I think that transmogs in retail shouldn’t be locked behind needing to play a version of Classic.
The biggest reason for playing Classic should be because you find Classic WoW’s gameplay fun whether that be era, hardcore, or a season.
Blizzard also likely doesn’t really care a whole lot about the specific metrics of a single mode beyond “is this popular enough to warrant keeping around?”. As long as we’re logging into WoW on a monthly basis for their MAU metric and subscription cost, they’re probably happy.
Trying to convince everybody to play SoD seems like a recipe to mix people who don’t want to be there with people who will resent them being there cause they just want to get their cosmetics and get out.
If things you got in classic with the appropriate challenge level were also unlocked in retail i’d play the crap out of it. It going both ways so retail unlocks show up in classic is a bit much however since things are much easier to unlock there.