Said this elsewhere - but for years wow never needed a catch up mechanic beyond āgearā. If your raid group wanted to help you gear up, you ran on an alt and they gave gear to you.
And no one complained.
Then legion happened with artifacts (again though - those had a pretty quick catch up mechanic built in - same as Azerite Power which isnāt what people are complaining about as by now you should be able to hit 65 in 2 weeks). Legendary drops were more of a problem but chances are youād get SOMETHING soon after hitting 120.
Thisā¦ is not the same thing. For the first time in WoW thereās a gate system that might require an alt to do hundreds of hours to catch up to a main. And one thatās time gated across weeks and weeks (mechagon, islands, rep etc).
The problem is work on your alts has never been particularly complicated beyond pushing pvp rankings. Thisā¦ is. Which is why many MANY people are saying its a terrible system.
If you canāt figure out ways to create an incentive for people to play alts outside of grinding time gated essences which have a direct correlation with power of your alt then youāre just as clueless as blizzard.
Basically this,
You said people āliterally asked for thisā - Who? Who asked for this? People have literally always hated doing daily content and the content didnāt unlock power for your character. It was optional.
In wrath of the lich king i had 3 alts so i could get more badges for mounts/pets from the Argent Tournament. It had no effect on my power, It made me feel good getting rewards quicker than I would have vs one character and it was completely optional
Lets say I want to make another monk. And for the sake of fairness lets assume Iām waiting till 8.3 so only need revered with Mechagon and Nazjatar
I need to grind azurite to 65+ to unlock the 3 slots. At a minimum Iām probably doing world quests that offer the rewards and daily 4 quest content. Probably other stuff as well.
I have to pvp. I need a bare minimum of 500 conquest to begin with (canāt remember what it is for rank 3). I also need to do pvp in Nazjatar and mechagon to unlock the achievement to unlock higher ranks of the other essence
I need to run mechagon 4? 5? times?
I need to do the islands for 4? weeks? So assuming I do heroic thats 4 runs - so 16 islands over 4 weeks
I probably need to do all the world quests in Nazjatar and do my followers quests on top of that. The second level pearl is 3000 follower experience so minimum of 10 days - I need double that and a 20 rank to get the final level 3 essence of the pearl
Eternal Palace - I need a lot of full runs. I canāt be bothered working out how many I need but I think its something like. 9/18/36? for the dps one. And I also have the tank and healer essences to collect - which I think are less - like. 3/9/Something? Anyway thats a LOT of runs (runs which will dry up when 8.3 happens. btw)
mechagon chests. so so so many chests. And a lot of galvanic oscillators. I think its something like 36 of the later PER ESSENCE to get it to level 3. So assuming I donāt get lucky - againā¦ I need 108 days of questing in this zone to get the oscillators I need. And thatās ignoring how many chests I need to farm (something likeā¦ 64 per spec - a whopping 192 from a scarce resource)
Oh. and yeah - as you pointed out thereās a +4, +7 and four or so +10 mythics to get.
Itās not so much about reasons to play alts, as it is to give lasting content for mains, something to work towards for more than just ālog on, raid, log outā.
65 is dumb easy to get. Please. I think my Rogue was 65 in all but 2 weeks.
Donāt need Rank 3 Conflict and Strife for Hot Trub. In fact, donāt need Hot Trub at all, itās a gimmick.
Vision of Perfection on a monk ? If you say so.
For what ?
Lucid Dream on a monk ? 3 weeks anyway.
Uh ? You need to do a single full clear of Heroic for Rank 2. Another full clear will get you Rank 3.
2 whole weeks. Of Heroic. Geez, āworkā.
Rank 3 is only a DPS upgrade.
3 +10s ?
I donāt see āhundreds of hoursā. I see like 2-3 hours per day for 3 weeks. At best, call it 42 hours.
Was gonna work on the DK next, but Iām doing a Priest now, just dinged 120 last night on it, itās fresh out of the upgrade mill. Itās my 9th 120.
So. - post on that? I want to be awed. I was at the original posters efforts.
Also a bunch of the things you responded to are stuff like āits just a dps increaseā. Wellā¦ yes. Yes it is. Why wouldnāt I want that? Or conflict and strife not being valuable for monks whenā¦ yeah it is. Especially if 8.3 changes to mistweaver go live.
If you want rank 3 across the board its a LOT of work.
Yes but you can just skip that. For essences on my alts, all I do daily in Nazjatar is the two puzzle quests and the odd time the pet quest (aside from the follower).
I dinged 120 on my shaman last night by doing Korrak stuff. It just kinda happened by accident. Then I realized what was ahead of me. Poor girl never had a chance.