If you had to write the expansion after Legion, and BFA was retconned

What story would you write? Would it be a horde vs alliance expansion like bfa? Would you have a big bad right from the start, or would you slowly build up future characters and villains for future expansions? What would the overall plot be? What would some of the character arcs be? Would you have new zones, or stay on the currently explored continents?

Let me know!

Don’t ask me to make stuff, man.

I only have two settings: Cutesy kawaii and mindbreaking weird.

Sylvanas starts to realize what she’s become and works to become a good leader that thinks long term rather than just trying to win at all costs.
Anduin realizes that he can’t keep being so naive and that he can’t change other people he can only change himself.
Illidan Stormrage loses the respect of the Illdari when their Hall Leader tells them about that cringey “I am my scars” line.
Ebon Blade apologizes to everyone about the whole grave robbing thing, but points out that it was for a good cause.
Xa’lath decides to stay with the Shadow Priest PC and they skip off into the sunset to commit blood sacrifice and feed ravens.
Alleria hears about the whole genocide thing and joins Horde.
Jaina still confronts the demons of her past, but you know without Ashvane to distract from her own mistakes, instead WoW becomes a courtroom drama show.
The End.

After defeating Sargeras together, we realize it’s not productive being racists and learn to accept each other’s differences. So we move onto playing with doggos.

3 Likes

I’m not sure of the path I would take, but It would be along the lines of having the Alliance and Horde having a close story line together in the early part then drifting apart with less and less ‘forced’ interaction as the game progresses. Rather than the BfA “I’m gonna kill you” more like a “leave us the heck alone.” True, there would be an endless rant about who had the better story (no change from what we have already). However, It all would be somewhat similar to the Battle for Mount Hyjal where we all worked together then drifted apart. The next expansion could be a soft reset of WoW where we started with a more or less clean slate.

I don’t think the “High sea” expansion theme was bad, but that war campain and Sylvanas leading the Horde magicly because of Vol’jin last words was cringy for me.

3 Likes

What about offending Cat lovers?

Edit: That also kinda favors Worgen.

Why should we worry about offending 2nd class citizens?

1 Like

after Legion? i would rewrite/retcon the entire thing after 5.2

I mean, if we are gonna go back that far. I’d prefer re-writing everything after vanilla.

TBC was a joke of a story. WotLK’s story was boring and cliche.

Then we should make a new game after warcraft 3, like one that night elves never joined alliance

TBC and wotLK story is waaay better and passable than the crap that came after mop

Id make twilight.

Because it would be super low effort, and the only case where something isnt a better love story than twilight.

Cuz bfa is a literal dumpsterfire.

At this point its hard for me to see anything lich king related as anything but a star wars rip off.

1 Like

And you think that everybody wants their race to be a Paladin now? Here comes the stampede.

After dealing with whoever the Big Bad is at the end of BFA, there’d be a peace treaty signed as both sides get rested and rebuild. Then as the next exp begins we’re still working together because our leaders finally realize that we should always start working together because there’s always a major threat at the end of the catastrophe that makes us work together any how.

But we the player characters get sent to the Second War by the Infinite Flight because the Infinite Flight sees us as threat to their plans in the future and sticking us an a totally different time line is their idea of the best way to stop us meddling kids.

Chromie manages to find us, and helps us find the mcguffin that will send us back home but its broken and we have to repair it by finding the parts at the end of the story line in re-imagined zones. Major lore characters would appear but hey, you’re a nobody and either they dismiss you as mad or don’t even bother with you because you’re a nobody so telling them about the future is useless.

After getting the pieces, you fight the Big Bad blocking you from going home, you defeat them and go home. Where the factions are now fighting and the peace treaty worthless because the Infinite Flight shockingly tricked people thanks to their shape shifting into our leaders. You then set off on an EPIC quest to save the leaders, save them, then face the real Big Bad at the end of the exp and win! Yay.

Either that or a dating sim.

I would give the Horde the Troll Expansion they have always wanted, while I would give the Alliance Pirates in the British Isles, and a bunch of Lovecraft themes.

I’d use the Expansion to finally kill off the Faction War, and unleash an Old God on to Azeroth. It would be so great, I’d call it


Let me think

Oh I got it


Spoiler

Battle for Azeroth

It’s got such an nice ring to it.

You mean sanlayn and updated model worgen?

Think about it.

Don’t know about the story but gameplay wise, here are some things off the top of my head.

Well first, I would listen to player feedback during the beta and PTR, which is something Blizzard hasn’t done.

Nightelves and Forsaken establish somewhere else in new capitals, not the ones from Kul’tiras or Dazar’alor and this before 8.1. Could see the cities work advance through patching.

I would add PVP vendors from the start because why break a working formula for 6-7 snowflakes that were unhappy and wanted a boring bar to fill up while doing nothing and getting gear that’s a downgrade at the end of the week.

On that note, War Supply Crate would get a tweak allowing for the gear that you get in it to not end up being a sure bet for the Scrapomatic.

Of course, currencies would make a triumphant return, because yet again it worked fine and like many things, did not need change.

Tier sets would also be making a return, because why in Aman’thul’s name would you remove an iconic progression feature that made the game more enjoyable and changed dynamics in rotation? Oh that’s right, because of Azerite gear!

NO MORE AZERITE GEAR.

Raid/Tier sets will look good and badass this time around, like they’re supposed to, and the people in charge of designing them for BFA end up either in the Stockades serving for a lifetime or are sent to be impaled on the Spires of Orgrimmar listening to a toy train set forever on 7.1 DTS surround sound system.

Primary stats get back to being more important than secondaries. Because duh.

Zones would be bigger in sizes (horizontally), but wouldn’t be the huge mess we have since a while with the exaggeration in maximizing space over verticality. Not every zone needs to be a vertical maze, lots of us actually like the flat designs of Mulgore for instance.

Also zones would be more of a single big continent, and less islandish.

Talents would be changeable on the go, as long as not in combat. Because why not really.

Glyphs making a return.

Skill trees making a return too, not sure if I’d keep the current Talent system.

Gladiator Stance makes a return as well as many pruned abilities, auras, etc, that made the game more enjoyable when classes had more than 4 buttons to press, or at least had options in using different stuff.

More Allied Races present at the start of the expansion, less time gating to get them.

Doubling the bags slots. Mechagon and Nazjatar alone are a pain in the ash sorting out your bags with the amount of useless junk taking all the space. We’re in 2019 Blizz, stop adding just 2 bags slots per new bags every expansion, it doesn’t make a damn difference.

Portals that used to be at locations where we used to have portals are still there. i.e. Org and SW portals in Shrines in Pandaria will get their other buddies back around them.

Reputation Quartermasters for say Mechagon, Nazjatar and well, pretty much all zones won’t have you need to spend $50-$75 in tokens to earn the Rep Mount you should have gotten when earning Exalted on the get go. At least it won’t be frickin’ 420k gold.

A rework of the personal loot system in raids, if not a total wipe of it.

The removal of the LFR tool for raids as a whole, however dungeons would keep the feature.

Island Expeditions and Warfronts are scrapped from the game for good and the people in charge of designing them are sent for a one way ticket to the Scrapomatic.

No more advantages towards Reputations for the Alliance, well Humans as it is greatly unbalanced for something as important as it being linked to stuff like Pathfinder, Warmode, etc.

The punchcards may get Scrapped for some kind of currency. Or at least will sell for more than an insulting 12 gold.

The weekly Tortollan quest will always be for gear, no more useless ressources or gold that you’d gain without even thinking doing other quests anyway.

Bonus: Ferals’ “meows” and Hunters’ pets annoying noises are muted when entering an Auction House.