If you had to listen to 1 song from your library on repeat forever

… what would it be and why?

Consider that you do not have the option of muting it, pausing it, or otherwise stopping it. It can be quiet, but it will be playing on repeat nonstop for the rest of your life. You have to deal with it. You are cursed.

A song you’re already aware of. Either you own it, you downloaded it, you bookmarked it, you saved it to a playlist, whatever. No googling the most neutral sounding thing you can find. It’s too late.

Let’s skip all of the “avoid the question” type songs in general. Instrumentals are fine, but no ambient / white noise, no silence, no “hidden track” songs with huge gaps between the listed song and the hidden track… no intermission songs that are clearly not meant to be a standalone experience. Those sorts of things. Yeah? Skip them.



My first thought was something instrumental. To make it a bit easier to fade into the background and pay less attention to. But I didn’t have much luck digging through my library. Everything was too somber, too heavy, too much bass, or it had some other quirk that’s fine for listening to it now and again, but would quickly make me go crazy if it was playing incessantly (for example, I love Hurdy Gurdy music, but the sound the instrument makes gets extremely grating after listening to nothing but it for an hour or so – I can’t imagine eternity).

So I gave up on that. I’m sure I could find something on YouTube, but I don’t have anything suitable. Non-English songs (to ignore the lyrics, at least) had mostly the same results. Mostly too heavy or too somber (lots of overlap on the artists here).

I ended up not finding anything that stood out as a “great” choice – I mean, you’re going to come to hate whatever you pick fairly quickly no matter what, right? – but I settled on this:

It’s one of my “calmer” songs, but without being super slow, sad, and, you know, stuff that’s gonna make me lethargic after an hour. It also seems just slightly… optimistic or something? That’s not quite the right term but we’ll stick with that. My only other songs that fit that bill are pretty blatantly Rock and Metal, which I tried to avoid.

(Also, if I wanted to hate myself and be incredibly anxious at all times:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UCHBClsDAjo)

2 Likes

That would be a nightmare regardless of the song.

22 Likes

Absolutely.

But you still have to make the choice, yeah?

I can’t sleep with music playing so I’d be dead in a few weeks from being unable to sleep.

why would you put this curse on me?

1 Like

Use this:

6 Likes

I would just turn off the music and not listen to any

1 Like

November Rain, that way I’d only have to listen to the whole thing 3 times before I died of old age.

6 Likes

Yep. Toto, Africa.

6 Likes

Don’t Worry, Be Happy. lol

1 Like
5 Likes

Valerie the Amy Winehouse version.

It’s literally an alarm tone on my phone.

The live BBC version is just amazing.

1 Like
5 Likes

Well, let’s see.

Dream Theater released “A View From the Top of the World” on Oct. 22. Pretty sure I got my CD (O.o) a week later. It’s been on repeat on my Mac since then, so at least 3 months.

I could pick “6 Degrees of Inner Turbulence”. I could pick “Count of Tuscany”, “Breaking All Illusions”, “Metropolis 2K”. If I wanted to cheat, maybe I could say “The Astonishing” since it’s clocks in at about 140m across 35 parts.

Anyway, that’s my short list.

I played Genesis Live at Wembly in 1987 for about 3 months too. What a great show.

3 Likes

Hello, I see you posted a thread about music. My god, there are so many! Since I want to go back and play the Yakuza games again, I’ll just go with this for right now:

Thanks for your post and have a great day!

Maybe you’ll get tired enough to sleep through it? I believe in you.

This the song that never ends. Yes, it goes on and on, my friend…

1 Like

I have a home recording studio, and I listen to songs I’m trying to dial in 100+ times before I get the mix as close as possible.

By that time, I don’t want to hear that song again for months and there is no way I could pick just one song for eternity.

Just imagine being stuck in an elevator with a muzak version of any song you thought you liked on infinite repeat…

The horror!
:ghost:

2 Likes
well, if i'm going to live with it forever, it's going have to be my favorite song
2 Likes

Honestly between that line of lyrics and how the song sounds I just thought of Russkaja and I refuse to explain why.

To be honest, this one I made; I’ve had it on repeat a few times in the past and I never got tired of it…

2 Likes