If you want to “shard” the like 1 - 10 zones for a week or two of Classic WoW, I don’t care. It’s whatever. If it helps with competition and server congestion go for it. No one cares.
But this “layering” idea is absolutely ridiculous. You’re layering EVERY zone? For an indeterminate amount of time? Are you freaking insane? Do you understand what this means?
So say you have a 200-person Real ID list…
P1: “Yo, anyone have any Rich Thorium up in your Silithus?”
P2: “Yeah bro, tons. No one is here”
P3: “Tons. Rode past like 3 just now, hop over”
Do you know why Arcanite Weapons are so desirable? The relative rarity and cost of acquisition. If you can just infinitely farm Rich Thorium by cycling through hundreds of layers with an organized RealID group this literally destroys the market on Arcane Crystals and by-proxy irrevocably upsets P1 server economy WHICH IS HALF OF THE END-GAME EXPERIENCE.
Replace Rich Thorium with… Devilsaurs? Black Lotus? AoE-farming spots in EPL?
P1: “Dudes, my Tanaris pirate cove is LOADED. Anyone have an empty layer for me?”
P2: “Inviting”
P3: “Mine has like 1 Alliance here. Come on over”
Do you appreciate what this does? At all?
One of my fondest Classic WoW memories was my Horde guild setting up “ambushes” for our biggest Alliance rival guild in Blackrock Mountain at 6:00pm on Tuesday nights… We knew they’d be amassing to raid and we would get a 30-40man group and “hide” inside and ambush them when they rode in. After like 2 weeks they would come “prepared” for our ambush and we’d have these epic PvP fights. They sort of had to… or else not raid…
But with “layering” what stops this guild from sending in a rogue and seeing the “ambush” and just swapping to another layer? Have you considered the impact this has on a server’s culture? Community? Economy? This is madness.
I will not come back to Classic WoW if you layer the entire world indefinitely because it’s not Classic WoW. You might as well just make a P-60 guild on retail. Hey, add some LFG functionality, Blizzard. Might as well, right? Both of the buddies I’ve spoken to about this since arriving home have also indicated they want nothing to do with “layering”.
I’m just one dude and you don’t care about me and I totally understand that. But the community you have that could make Classic really succeed doesn’t want this and won’t tolerate it. This solution panders to a crowd that won’t stick around anyway. The people that understand the ramifications of “layering” won’t play, and the type of people that don’t care (or even support it) won’t be staying anyway…
P.S. INB4 “It’s only for like a week dude, chill.” I don’t believe that for a moment.