Well actually it’s fine w/e but could I please have some way to turn it into an item?
I don’t bind my hearthstone on my bars so I like to open my bag and right click it from there. But that means I don’t ever use any of these new cosmetic hearthstones. I’d love if there was an option to say right click the toy and “create hearthstone” or something just for people who like to have a physical hearthstone.
Uh, yea this accually isn’t a terrible idea
I’ll even bind my HS toy to use and still end up opening my bag to use that one from years of conditioning
Just have it so you delete your normal one, then just as you said give the option to make a physical version
Integrating the Hearthstone client with the toy is actually not a bad idea. Imagine people HS dueling outside the Orgrimmar auction house.
I like to stack size buffs until I’m as large as Stormwind Keep.
Doesn’t matter what we like. That’s not how it’s designed anymore and we are in such a minority that we can never hope to gain traction on these issues.
Toy option is way better because it doesn’t take up bag space.
To use, go to your toy collection and pull up the hearthstone toy you want to use. Then, drag it on your action bar.
If not creating a physical hearth from the toy hearths, maybe if someone has any ‘extra’ hearths in collections they get a ‘Hearthstone box’ toy, that when used lets you select which unlocked hearth appearance the base hearthstone will use. Could be similar to how Vulpera can choose which found & unlocked visual they have for their bag of tricks it will use, by using their seperate ‘rummage your bag’ racial (https://www.wowhead.com/spell=312425/rummage-your-bag)
Maybe they could implement a shift+click option for you to do that. I know nothing about coding, but it makes sense to me. 
Alternatively, since this option isn’t available for you yet (I’ll cross my fingers, because I see nothing wrong with more options for people), you can favorite the hearthstone you use from your toy box and instead of opening your bag, you can keybind the collections tab and click it from there?
Having the option to override your actual hearthstone in your bags would be nice.
lmao.
My full bags 24/7 disagree with you, but to each their own.
I do use the OPie addon, so I only keybind the addon, and have rings filled with mounts, hearthstone toys, professions and other utility stuff.
Wait! Our Hearthstone is a Toy now? What about the one for our Garrison? or to get to the Shipyard? or the one to get to Dalaran?
Not sure if this is a troll comment or really not knowing about the toy hearths, but they are referring to the cosmetic hearthstone toys that only exist in collections that give special visual effects when using them to hearth, such as:
And how they would like if they could be turned into a physical hearthstone that can be clicked in the bag to use that alternate visual effect rather than the default one.
Short of a ‘create a hearth’ the OP suggested, or using an alternate means such as the ‘choose your available unlocked visual effect for your default hearth’ method like rummage your bags mentioned above, I don’t know how easy it would be to implement code wise.
No, those are still items that you have to carry on your bags and click when you want to use them.
But there are toys that you use as a hearthstone, just with a difference appearance. Here is a list from wowhead:
If you don’t have the hearthstone item, go to any Inn and make that Inn your home. A hearthstone will be created in an open bag slot.
If one isn’t created, then you have the item somewhere. Probably your bank.
Then you would probably be very upset if you didn’t get the awesome Hearthstone horse mount available only during MoP.