That was my best time in Wow, starting with BC, when “Last Season’s Arena Set” was from regular battleground honor. It got me really into Battleground PVP, while the set was actually a good Epic set for general solo PVE play.
I always have thought it was crazy when they caved, having PVE gear be the best for PVP. It wasn’t what the PVE’rs mainly did anyway, so it just seemed so dumb.
I’d actually DO warmode, if PVP gear was still that way. I’d get last season’s arena set, then bother to have warmode on.
Those sets were not that bad for PVE either, since my Bm Hunters was not replaced until 7 levels into wrath. Before that, she was just so incredibly buff that it made soloing in Wrath a Breeze (with that BC “Last season’s Arena set.”)
This character was the same, using the last season’s arena set near the end of MOP as my regular gear. It was then not replaced, for regular solo PVE, until the Timeless Isle came along with those excellent PVE sets you could get.
The irony is this would have made Warmode SO much better, with more people being involved. If you could still get a PVP set, which was the best for PVP (totally destroying people in PVE sets, as you could back then) then it would have revitalized PVP. I would bother to do battlegrounds again, to get the “last season’s arena set”, to then use in Warmode (or they could have also let you purchase it with honor/stuff from Warmode.)
The reason it worked well, getting that Last Season’s Set with regular battleground honor, was that as you got more pieces of the set you were WAY more buff for PVP. So I started out feeling cruddy in battlegrounds, then ended up feeling like I was super buff.
The change, of just letting the best PVE gear be the best for PVP, ruined PVP for me. It also made Warmode, a big feature of this expansion, pointless.