Hot-take: If Slyvanas gets Redeemed, so should Arthas

He was a good boy, who didn’t do anything wrong.

He got his soul stolen by an evil sword, and nothing he did as an agent of the scourge, or as the Lich King was actually him.

Facts yo.

2 Likes

Only if they’re allowed a double wedding.

1 Like

Yea, if they are going to glorify the genocide of the Night Elves, they might just do the same thing with the genocide of the High Elves.

Also portray it as a good thing what Arthas did to Sylvanas.

5 Likes

Don’t we remember Uther in the halls of reflection?

Saying that the only reason the scourge isnt just swarming all of azeroth is because a piece of Arthas is restraining them?

Arthas is way more of a good guy than Suevanas

4 Likes

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bB7fgX6H9_M

Yes, focus on that anger. Hold onto it as you begin to realize Sylvanas is here to stay.

I’m fully expecting Sylvanas to get Kerriganed. However, I would actually be pretty upset if they redeemed Arthas. Frostmourne corrupted him, sure, but there was a darkness in him all along. That’s part of what made his story so interesting.

They really should just bang it out.

lol “if” they redeem her.

Story team is already cooking up some hot garbage for us.

2 Likes

Honestly, Arthas is more worthy of being redeemed than sylvanas.

We know he wasnt in control from the moment he took frostmorne on, before then he made mistakes. But nothing worthy of eternal damnation.

Meanwhile we know form warcraft 3 that Sylvanas is in complete control and has preformed acts way worse.

I dont want to see an arthas redemption that badly, but I’d be more okay with it than one for sylvanas.

4 Likes

I am going to guess this is referring to him culling Strathholm (sp?). I will agree that it was extreme to cull the entire city, but the plague of underneath was spreading so rapidly with no means of a cure. He commited an evil act to do good in the long run.

Edit: Forgot to mention that this was an actual morally grey decision.

1 Like

Only Arthas with boobs can be redeemed

1 Like

Especially considering until he led an undead army back from Northrend it would seem that Lordaeron had it under control.

they should just bring back Garrosh … he was a true leader

I want Arthas, Sylvannas, and Garrosh to all sacrifice themselves to save Azeroth from whatever the last boss is.

They get redeemed by saving the world but get destroyed and become part of the aether so we never have to deal with them again.

I agree, he was an Orc that acted like an Orc.

1 Like

Neither should get redeemed.

He lead that army after picking up Frostmourn. That, in my opinion, is when he got corrupted and lost control of his sense of self.

I love Arthas but I do not want him to get redeemed, he’s a tragic villain and that makes him part of why he’s so interesting. On the other hand I just hope Sylvanas dies a horrible death and stays down.

Off topic tho, Y’all think Arthas is single in the Maw? Yes/no?

1 Like

Right, but it contributed to his decline.

Nah, they could choose to give both of them redemption stories but there is no obligation to do so.