My biggest sense of disconnect is every in-game character comments how horrible and wretched the Maw is. Like, apparently, its very sight is appalling and fear-inspiring. And I just don’t see it.
Sure, the River of Souls is moderately unsettling, as are the “rock prisons” and like… Souls half-crafted into armor. But even then, they aren’t actual characters, they’re just the simple, micro-torso silhouette.
Otherwise, like… What’s scary about it? It’s just some rocks, and a few cages. Like, I get we gotta keep a T Rating, but Naxxaramas is hella scarier than the Maw, as are the Forsaken. I’m told the souls are tortured, but I see no implements for this? Like, I sound a lot edgier than I am (“i need more graphically-depicted torture in my game, pls”), but if it’s a realm of torment, at least show me the torment. Hell, Googling “SCP” gives some pretty good inspiration for horrifying monsters that could probably fit in the T Rating, and could easily have been warped/manipulated souls.
And, the mechanics are so slow. Like… “immediate extermination” takes like 10 minutes to kill you. Ocean fatigue kills you faster. The Mawsworn Abductors are a cool concept, but they only strike like once every 15 minutes, and you have 20 seconds to kill them. The assassins are my favorite: they hit decently-hard, have killed me a few times, and come in different varieties. The mount limitations don’t make it “scarier”, they make it like trudging through mud.
That said, as a druid main…