I’m at 12 renown for Hallowfall Arathi, and just realized I never got the quest to get the ilevel 584 trinket (Empowered Tinderbox) from Raen Dawncavalyr at renown 11. When I talk to her it just shows an inventory of helm appearances.
EDIT: After checking my old 571 Empowered Tinderbox from the renown 5 quest, it has automatically upgraded to 584! So even though it says there will be quest, it just upgrades your old one.